Surfish Bistro

Reviews

• HB

  Hannah Balla

  Feb 15, 2026
  1.0
  Served a meal with shellfish in it despite being explicitly told about the allergy beforehand. Resulted in the person having an allergic flair up, which thankfully they were ok afterwords considering they did not have their epipen on hand. Could have gone extremely wrong in different circumstances. The meal was also not comped, which again, given the circumstances, would have been the very least that could have been done. If you have food based allergies, be very wary!
• SN

  Shaggy N.

  Feb 6, 2026
  5.0
  This place never disappoints. It’s very consistent and the food is really great. The portions are also amazing. 10/10
• MM

  Mariya Mindyuk

  Feb 4, 2026
  3.0
  This restaraunt has been on my go-to list for quite a while so when opportunity presented itself today, I had high expectations. We started off with some coffee. The coffee was watery, definitely do not recommend. Complimentary chips for the table were pretty good. It was a nice mix and the chips were not too oily. The two sauces that came with were very mildly spiced. We ordered a total of 4 dishes. The tuna ceviche was nicely portioned. The pineapple was NOT prepared as described on the menu. Overall, while the fish was fresh, the sauce was too sweet and the whole dish felt like the ingredients were assembled haphazardly instead of being cohesive. The beet salad was also assembled, not mixed. There was very little feta cheese, too much dressing, and the vinegrette was too sweet. The black paella was a highlight. Beautifully cooked squid and octopus, though the shrimp was rubbery and tough. The squid ink rice was creamy but definitely on the salty side. The clams and mussels were well cooked but not well prepared, there was quite a bit of grit I ended up chewing through. The chicken entree was juicy. The chicken was beautifully cooked. Meh side mashed potatoes, good but nothing to write home about. I was surprised by how mildly seasoned the dish was. Entrees took a very long time, almost 50 minutes. The dishes were beautifully presented, and the dinnerware was gorgeous. I wish the staff had removed the stickers off the coffee mug bottoms. Overall, very happy to have made the trip, will not make it again.
• LS

  Leah Shibilski

  Jan 15, 2026
  4.0
  A very laid back dining experience on a Monday night. Drinks and dessert were great! Would not recommend the duck pasta… though the pasta and sauce were decent, I just didn’t end up liking it and should have ordered the paella like everyone else! lol The plantain chips and nuts as a starter were DELICIOUS and I LOVED the sauce and salsa they came with.
• MK

  Monica Kh

  Jan 11, 2026
  5.0
  Very pleasant staff. We reserved for 13ppl and showed up 20 and they never gave attitude or hard time . Food was very fresh, esp ceviches - wow, amazed They were very attentive , very friendly and quick