Customers praised the pizza for its flavor and quality, with many considering it some of the best in Brooklyn, though there were complaints about inconsistency and undercooked items.
Customer Service
While many reviews highlighted friendly and attentive staff, there were notable complaints about poor service, particularly regarding order accuracy and handling of complaints.
Pricing
The pricing was generally viewed as reasonable for the area, but some customers felt certain items were overpriced, especially when considering the quality.
Delivery Issues
Several customers reported problems with delivery, including incorrect orders and delays, which negatively impacted their overall experience.
DM
David Menchini
4 days ago
5.0
Park Slope classic and criminally underrated in my opinion. 10/10
KR
Kiri Rain
Feb 9, 2026
5.0
Great food made by great people. When my delivery got stolen, they immediately sent me a new order with a little extra chicken to make up for it. Thank you Pino’s!
KL
Khari Linton
Feb 7, 2026
5.0
I organize a group of folks to play tennis once a month at Propsect Park, and we always order from Pino's. The pizzas are always fresh and arrive on time. We trust Pino's every time.
DL
Daniel Lis
Jan 18, 2026
1.0
Paid over $50 for delivery of a prosciutto arugula pizza and slice of carrot cake. Received a cheese pizza, was refused a refund or any accomodation, was offered a $5 refund after following up a second time despite the difference being $11 and still being stuck with the wrong order. Very disappointed.