Pies 'n' Thighs

Reviews

• RB

  roberto burgos

  Nov 13, 2025
  5.0
  My buddy’s took me here for dinner and it wasn’t what I expected it sort of looked like a fast food spot but is actually a place you can sit and enjoy some great food good music nice people that work there waitress was very attentive we all had the chicken box fantastic and there banana cream pie phenomenal.. cant wait to go back.. had a great time…
• HP

  Hilary P

  Nov 11, 2025
  4.0
  The service was friendly, proactive and helpful. The food was outstanding. The building is Hopper-esque. They have a tight, focused menu and the only dish that appealed to me was sold out at 7.30pm on a Sunday. Sadly. So i had biscuits and gravy. Outstanding gravy. Not a fan of biscuits, they looked awesome though! I would definitely take a southerners there again.
• GP

  Gracie Patten

  Nov 11, 2025
  5.0
  Classic diner atmosphere with good beverages and desserts. We got the vegetarian “chicken” biscuit and three sides - coleslaw, black eyed peas, and mac n cheese. The biscuit on which the chicken sandwich was served was hot and delicious, and it was dressed with a honey butter and hot sauce. The sides were good as well, though the mac n cheese was nothing to write home about. The real reason we came was the banana cream pie which was incredible - a perfect dessert. We also had a cup of coffee and the sour cherry lemonade.
• HP

  Human Person

  Nov 9, 2025
  2.0
  Ive been coming here for about a year and used to love this place. As of august of this year they changed up the menu and increased prices across the board which mildly worried me, but i stood by them through it and hoped they wouldnt change anything else. Recently though not only have the prices increased, but portion sizes have dropped. Both my orders of fries i got to go came half empty. My girlfriend's biscuits and gravy came without gravy. Would NOT reccomend going unless they revert prices and portion sizes.
• EC

  Esmeralda Chavarin

  Oct 30, 2025
  5.0
  Pies’n’Thighs is one of the best spots in Williamsburg for southern comfort food, handmade pastries and local craft beer. Their cinnamon roll is incredible - chefs kiss! It’s soft, buttery, you can tell they’re fresh from that morning - think Cinnabon but better. I’m always down for a sweet treat and everything here hits - the pies, the pecan crunch donut, ugh everything is just so good when it’s made from scratch and so much care. The Hippie Banjo for brunch (hello Sprouts!) and the Fried Catfish Plate are my other favorites. I love their sandwich bread (pro tip I think you can buy it) and the tarter sauce for that catfish is perfection. They also carry really good local craft beer from other half, evil twin and Grimm, which makes dinner and weekend brunch even better. The staff is always friendly and knowledgable- they know exactly what to recommend- the GM even told Me about their new ice cream shop, Heap’s Ice Cream ,where they use Pies’n’Thighs pastries for ice cream sandwiches (like what, def going next time) Last week I tried the chicken tenders (I think they’re only in house) and they were juicy, crunchy and full of flavor. The sauces were great too but I’m a Ranch girl through and through. The food and drinks give an elevated vibe at night, but it’s also the perfect cozy bakery to stop for coffee and pastries on the way to work. I highly recommend Pies’n’Thighs - good food, good vibes and the nicest staff.

Frequently Asked Questions About Pies 'n' Thighs