Pies 'n' Thighs

Reviews

• NN

  Na'Tasha

  5 days ago
  5.0
  Love this place! So happy I finally had a chance to taste the pie (I’m usually stuffed from the chicken). A BK staple for sure .
• JJ

  J Jope

  Jan 5, 2026
  1.0
  Left New York 3 years ago came back to visit and took my fiancé here. This was his first time visiting NY. He was searching for some good breakfast, so I highly suggested pies and thighs. Must say was very disappointed. The chicken was horrible, tasted like old oil was used. The waffles were cold and hard, the Mac and cheese were cold and a bit hard. Not sure if it’s a new chef. However, was very very disappointed.
• CC

  Cho

  Dec 26, 2025
  5.0
  I had a quick order and puck up in this sweet place and couldn’t be happier with the service provided along with the food quality. From the first seconds I entered the place I got this warm, homie, cozy dinner feeling. Girls who work here are super nice. One of them helped me with my order customization as I don’t eat all the ingredients offered initially on the menu. She was very understanding and real professional. Food was prepared clean and fast. I lived the sandwich I ordered. There were some tempting pies on display. One of the tables was a family with little kids and they all were having a blast! The rest of the guests also seemed to be very comfortable. You could tell this place is more than just a place to grab a bite. Definitely coming back. Prices are fair, flavor was amazing, people and the facility also amazing!
• DD

  didobrov

  Dec 18, 2025
  5.0
  Pies n’ Thighs was fantastic!!! My boyfriend and I came in to dine in on a Thursday evening and there was plenty of room to sit, although there is not much seating in the restaurant as a whole. We started off with a lemonade, a sour cherry lemonade, and the fried pickles. I had the sour cherry lemonade and it was great - super sweet and sour, very tart. It tasted like real sour cherry, not the artificial stuff. My boyfriend said his lemonade was great too. The pickles were good, but the true stand-out of the pickle dish was the ranch. I LOVE ranch. Leavitt St Tavern (in Chicago), Wing Stop, and Lou Malnati’s (Chicago) rank among my top ranches, and I have to say - Pies n’ Thighs ranks up there with the top few. Their ranch was so so so good I got extra for my chicken as well. For mains, my boyfriend had the Chicken Biscuit, I had 3 tenders, and we got three sides to share including mashed potatoes, mac n’ cheese, and a biscuit. My boyfriend loved the chicken biscuit (though the portion was a little small, although reasonably priced), and my chicken tenders were super crispy and very very juicy. I also did not anticipate them being so big (twice the size of Cane’s!!!) and was only able to finish two - my boyfriend made himself a sandwich out of the extra biscuit and my third tender hahaha. The mac n’ cheese was not exceptional and was a little grainy (maybe they didn’t cook the flour out completely?), and neither were the mashed potatoes, BUT the biscuit is definitely worth your money. It’s soft and chewy on the inside, and so so crispy and crunchy on the outside. It’s probably the best biscuit I’ve ever had. And the honey butter that it comes with - FANTASTIC! The service was very nice too! We liked our waitress, and she was very very patient with a little toddler causing a bit of a ruckus hahaha sitting at the table beside us. Also, we forgot our leftover fried pickles on the way out, and she ran after us as we were standing on the corner of the street to hand them to us. Overall, this place is an 11/10! We’ll have to come back and try the pie - we didn’t have a chance to since we were so stuffed!!!
• MB

  Marco Bellotti

  Dec 18, 2025
  4.0
  I wish I could say more but I can’t give 5 stars but just because I actually had an americano and a cinnamon roll . Loved it : super affordable prices (in general, I had a look at the menu) and the cinnamon is HUGE! So don’t take 2 if you’re two people ahaha but that was good, I can tell. Big shout out to the service: the people treating is amazing SUPER CUTE AND COZY LOCATION

Frequently Asked Questions About Pies 'n' Thighs