At Papa Johns Pizza in Brooklyn, NY, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it's our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Brooklyn pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Brooklyn or stop by 1915 Nostrand Ave for carryout to order the best pizza in Brooklyn, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Numerous customers reported long wait times for delivery and pickup, with some orders taking over two hours.
Food Quality
Feedback on food quality was mixed, with some praising the pizza while others complained about it being oily, undercooked, or poorly made.
Staff Behavior
Several reviews highlighted rude or unprofessional behavior from staff, contributing to a negative customer experience.
Order Accuracy
Customers frequently mentioned issues with incorrect orders and missing items, indicating a lack of attention to detail.
Positive Experiences
Despite the negative feedback, some customers praised the pizza quality and friendly service, indicating that experiences can vary.
JE
Jenyah Eliacin
2 days ago
1.0
Ordered from this place online I got a simple wings and 2 pizzas and it was supposed to take 30 minutes it took over an hour and a half just for my dasher to get the food and he’s been waiting in there. It was way too expensive for this type of service and the place seems to be understaffed. They also seem to prioritize walk ins more than online even if they accept it. This was my first time ordering from this place and it will be my last.
DT
Diallo Thierno
3 days ago
1.0
Ordered pickup papa bites and a small pizza, paid extra for a side of ranch. When I came to pick it up I asked if the ranch was in the box she confirmed that it was in there. Come to find out there was no ranch and not even the marinara sauce that comes with the papa bites
OK
Oleksandra Koval
Jan 30, 2026
1.0
Placed an order on the app at 3pm, it wasn't delivered until almost 6. Insane considering we're down the block from them.
AC
Aisha Chaudrey
Dec 11, 2025
1.0
Mediocre would be too generous regarding food quality. Staff are very unpleasant. Don't order if you're coming after work unless you want to wait at least an hour, you'll regret not just cooking✔️