Dave and Buster's Brooklyn - Atlantic Center

Reviews

• GG

  Gabrielle Gordon

  2 days ago
  1.0
  Edit to add- I already contacted your support feel free to push through that refund since someone replied here. Server got fired after saying hello and taking our drink order. No one thought to move tables to another section or give us a heads up. Basically left to fend for ourselves for 2 hours. I ordered food at the bar instead of my table and had no utensils. Had to use cocktail napkins we grabbed from the bar also. Absolutely horrendous service experience. When we mentioned the 3 drinks we ordered THE ONLY THING WE ORDERED at the table that took over an hour to move from the bar should be comped at this point we got ignored.
• RD

  Ricardo Durand

  5 days ago
  5.0
  Millie was PHENOMENAL! Very attentive, constantly checked on us I couldn't ask for a better server.
• VS

  Vanitas Shyguy

  Mar 28, 2026
  3.0
  Food was amazing, the servers forgot napkins, fork and straws but the food was great and the service was good.
• MG

  Mikhail Giuseppi

  Mar 25, 2026
  3.0
  I reserved a table at Dave & Buster’s Atlantic Plaza for my birthday, and honestly, the experience was disappointing. Not one staff member acknowledged my birthday. No “happy birthday,” no small gesture, nothing to make it feel special, which was surprising since we had a reservation. When we were seated, the table was dirty. I had to wait an over a half hour before someone came to clean it, which didn’t leave a great first impression. I already fished my first drink and still there at a nasty table…The service overall was inconsistent. Our waitress brought the wrong margarita more than once. The classic margarita didn’t taste good at all, but the watermelon one she brought by mistake was actually better. The rest of cocktails…oh dear 😬😬 Happy hour prices were good, but the drinks themselves were hit or miss. On a positive note, the food was solid no great not bad…No complaints there, and the game and food combo deal was a good value. What really stood out to me was that the place wasn’t even busy. It was a Monday, so I expected better service. Simple things like clean seating, correct orders, and basic attention to a birthday reservation should be standard. Especially seeing I even told them it’s my birthday!! I still tipped 20% because I work in the service industry and understand how it can be, but overall, the experience felt underwhelming. Dave & Buster’s Atlantic Plaza definitely has room to improve, especially when it comes to service and making special occasions feel special.
• EC

  El Croft

  Mar 24, 2026
  5.0
  I had a wonderful time and the food was excellent. My bartender Bryan was the absolute best and made sure everything was excellent. Definitely recommend going there anytime