Many customers praised the pizza for its deliciousness and authentic New York flavor, while some expressed disappointment with tasteless or poorly made pizzas.
Service
The staff received mixed reviews; while many found them friendly and attentive, others reported slow service and issues with order accuracy.
Atmosphere
The pizzeria is described as cozy and welcoming, making it a neighborhood staple, although some noted it can be small and crowded.
Consistency
Several customers highlighted the establishment's reliability in food quality and service over the years, though a few mentioned recent declines.
KB
Kodie Banks
Feb 12, 2026
5.0
They are always pleasant and easy to talk to. When I call and indecisive I'm never rushed. There are many pizzeria closer to me yet Danny's feels like home. The kids love their pizza and it's never a disappointment. They are consistent with their flavor and authenticity. Hands down one of the best in Brooklyn 🤌🏿
CC
Christine
Feb 10, 2026
1.0
Pizza came cold.
CO
Carlos Ovalle
Feb 3, 2026
5.0
Incredible pizza, incredible staff, incredibly cozy to share a slice with someone. This is true New York pizza and it’s right next to the train station, an absolute must if you’re in the area or order from home!
KF
Kate Filina
Jan 23, 2026
5.0
Best local spot, friendly staff and delicious pizza.
PL
Peter Larios
Jan 17, 2026
5.0
Got margherita pizza and a beef patty here after a show. Awesome NYC pizza place highly recommend