Customers had mixed experiences with the food; while many praised specific dishes like pizza and brunch items, others found certain meals bland or poorly executed.
Service
Service received high marks for being friendly and attentive, though some reviews noted inconsistencies and slow service during busy times.
Atmosphere
The restaurant is described as having a welcoming and cozy atmosphere, making it a popular choice for both casual dining and special occasions.
Value
Some customers felt the prices were reasonable for the quality of food and service, while others considered certain items overpriced given their experience.
LP
L P0171
Dec 23, 2025
1.0
You won’t convince me any of the food is made from scratch. The Caesar salad is incredibly bland. Just romaine with tasteless, store bought dressing. Extremely disappointed I spent money here and won’t return.
GD
Geneva Davis
Dec 16, 2025
5.0
I really enjoyed the brunch menu, the food was really good!! I had the steak & eggs.
AM
Anita Mires
Dec 16, 2025
5.0
Carefully prepared and uncommonly delicious food. We savored every bite! The staff were attentive and courteous and we enjoyed being in the space very much. Thank you!
Frequently Asked Questions About Black Oak on Fifth
What are the regular operating hours of Black Oak on Fifth?
Black Oak on Fifth is open Monday through Thursday from 4:00 PM to 11:00 PM, Friday from 3:00 PM to 11:00 PM, Saturday from 10:00 AM to 3:40 PM and 4:00 PM to 11:00 PM, and Sunday from 10:00 AM to 3:40 PM and 4:00 PM to 10:00 PM.
Does Black Oak on Fifth offer delivery services?
Yes, Black Oak on Fifth provides delivery services with delivery hours mostly from 4:15 PM to 10:40 PM on weekdays and extended hours on weekends.
Can I pick up my order in-store at Black Oak on Fifth?
Yes, in-store pickup is available at Black Oak on Fifth during their takeout hours.
What types of cuisine does Black Oak on Fifth serve?
Black Oak on Fifth specializes in Italian and New American cuisine, offering pasta, pizza, and vegan options, among others.
Where is Black Oak on Fifth located?
Black Oak on Fifth is located at 200 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217, USA.
Where can I view the menu or place an order online for Black Oak on Fifth?
You can view the menu and place an order online at https://blackoakonfifth.com/menu.
What is the price range at Black Oak on Fifth?
Black Oak on Fifth has a price range of two dollar signs, indicating moderate pricing.
What nearby wellness center can I visit before dining at Black Oak on Fifth?
You can visit Growing Space Acupuncture and Wellness, which offers acupuncture and holistic health services, conveniently located near Black Oak on Fifth.
Are there any cafes close to Black Oak on Fifth for a pre- or post-meal coffee?
Yes, Grounded Cafe is nearby and is a great option for a coffee stop before or after your meal at Black Oak on Fifth.
Can customers combine a visit to Black Oak on Fifth with a fitness or yoga class nearby?
Absolutely, Brooklyn Flow, a yoga studio and gym, is close by, making it convenient for customers to enjoy a workout and then a meal at Black Oak on Fifth.