Many customers reported issues with food being cold, undercooked, or incorrect orders, leading to dissatisfaction.
Service Issues
Numerous reviews highlighted poor service, including long wait times, inattentive staff, and incorrect orders.
Cleanliness Concerns
Several customers noted unsanitary conditions, including dirty tables and reports of cockroaches.
Positive Staff Interactions
Despite the negative feedback, some customers praised specific staff members for their excellent service and attentiveness.
Atmosphere
The restaurant was described as a good place to watch sports, with a lively atmosphere and ample TV screens.
SL
Sharilyn Catherine Langston
Oct 10, 2025
1.0
The food is disgusting.
DO
Dallas O
Oct 7, 2025
1.0
Food is ok. Service is horrible. Doesn't matter if you just order some buffalo chicken dip they take a half hour to come out with it
BW
Bryan Walters
Oct 5, 2025
1.0
It is absolutely unacceptable what has happened to this Buffalo Wild Wings location. This was the last straw!! Its now the FOURTH, not second not third but the FOURTH TIME in a row that my order has been completely butchered. Things missing, wrong items. What has happened to this place!! This used to be one of the best B dubz around just a few years ago!!
TS
Tyler smith
Oct 5, 2025
1.0
App was down tried to call in
No, one helped me on the phone had to drive down. Basically, I spent from 12:30 PM till 2:15 PM, trying to order 2 hrs until I actually got my food. At the restaurant
AJ
Alejandro Javier
Aug 17, 2025
2.0
Si eres mexicano y quieres tomar más de una cerveza por hora en las mesas, no vengas ,sobre todo si tienes familia ,por que la manager dijo que, solo puedes una cerveza por hora aun cuando eramos 8 personas ,con dos niños pequeños , en barra quizá te sirvan más
Frequently Asked Questions About Buffalo Wild Wings
What type of food does Buffalo Wild Wings in Bay Shore, NY specialize in?
Buffalo Wild Wings in Bay Shore offers award-winning Buffalo, New York-style wings with a choice of 26 sauces and seasonings.
What are the operating hours for Buffalo Wild Wings in Bay Shore?
Buffalo Wild Wings is open from 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM every day of the week.
Where is Buffalo Wild Wings located in Bay Shore, NY?
It is located at 1701 Sunrise Highway, Bay Shore, NY 11706, United States.
How can I contact Buffalo Wild Wings in Bay Shore?
You can reach Buffalo Wild Wings at +1 631-517-1987.
Does Buffalo Wild Wings in Bay Shore offer takeout services?
Yes, Buffalo Wild Wings is categorized as a takeout restaurant along with being a sports bar and chicken wings restaurant.
Can I find Buffalo Wild Wings online?
Yes, Buffalo Wild Wings Bay Shore has several online pages including their official website: https://www.buffalowildwings.com/locations/us/ny/bay-shore/1701-sunrise-hwy/sports-bar-1190/
What nearby shopping centers can I visit before or after dining at Buffalo Wild Wings?
Bayshore Mall and Moll De Bay Shore are nearby shopping centers where you can shop before or after dining at Buffalo Wild Wings.
Are there other dining options near Buffalo Wild Wings in Bay Shore?
Yes, nearby dining options include Taco Bell, Checkers, Popeyes® Louisiana Kitchen, Lasaka House of Noodles, Charleys Cheesesteaks, Subway, and Sarku Japan.
What nearby stores sell sportswear near Buffalo Wild Wings?
Finish Line, Zumiez, and DICK'S Sporting Goods are nearby stores where you can find sportswear.
Are there beauty and spa services close to Buffalo Wild Wings in Bay Shore?
Yes, Aura Nails, Miss Nail, and Hair Madness offer beauty salon and spa services near Buffalo Wild Wings.