Upon returning from WWII my Dad, Dino Pacciotti, started working at the Bocce Club on Hickory St in Buffalo. The club had bocce ball courts in the yard and served drinks & sandwiches inside. In 1946, Mr. Pacciotti seized the opportunity to purchase the club. He soon found an old pizza oven in the basement and started experimenting. He formulated his own unique pizza recipe and Bocce Club Pizza was born. In 1959, Dino moved into the Bailey Ave location in Amherst, seeing the proximity to UB South campus as a big positive. In 1988, our Hopkins Rd location in Williamsville opened, not far from UB North campus.
Bocce Club Pizza uses only the freshest and most natural ingredients from 100% whole milk mozzarella cheese to dough made from scratch and hand stretched daily. We also mix our secret pizza sauce each and every day.
I am very proud and humbled to carry on the “Buffalo Tradition” my father started so many years ago.
Customers frequently praised the pizza for its great taste, with many calling it the best in Buffalo.
Service Issues
Several reviews highlighted inconsistent service, including delays in order fulfillment and issues with order accuracy.
Staff Friendliness
Many customers noted the staff as friendly and helpful, contributing positively to their experience.
Inconsistency
Some customers reported a decline in food quality and service consistency over time, indicating a need for improvement.
MB
Matt Bissett
Jan 4, 2026
1.0
DO NOT DO DELIVERY!
It’s been 2 hours and our food isn’t here. When I ordered I was told it could take up to an hour and that was fine by me, but sitting two hours later and still not having it, I called and asked and they said it would be leaving soon. No apology or sorry we’re busy or sorry it’s late, instead I had someone who was annoyed at me calling and asking nicely for an update.
Customer service is always rough here and this is my first time doing delivery and I will never do that again.
I’ve had the food plenty of times and it’s great food, it just sucks that it is terribly run.
WC
William Clarkson
Jan 3, 2026
5.0
Food is always great every time I order from Bocce! Always ready when they say, and sometimes even ahead of time.
JS
Jodie Smith
Dec 29, 2025
2.0
After placing an online order and being told 45 minutes for a simple sandwich and a few wings it’s now been over an hour and 20 minutes that I have been waiting for my food.
I would complain to the people at the service area, but they’re 18-year-old kids who really don’t care about Work. Funny, I was reluctant to order but thought the wings sounded good because last time I ordered there was such a wait for just a sandwich. it’s a Monday if you can’t produce something In an hour, then you have a problem.
TS
Tina Stanford
Dec 24, 2025
5.0
Home for Christmas and bought a large cheese and pepperoni pizza Christmas Eve Eve. The line was consistently long but fast moving, full of others with the same idea. The staff were polite and efficient. The pizza was excellent like I remember from my youth. The dough, the cheese, great pepperoni and of course, the Sauce!!
MM
m camm (Mike)
Dec 21, 2025
5.0
Always efficient and if you don’t know this is the best pizza in WNY yet, you haven’t tried it. Best app for ordering too, btw. Just need to fix being able to place “future” orders. Only allows you to select same day.
Bocce Club Pizza is located at 4174 Bailey Ave, Amherst, NY 14226, USA.
What are the operating hours of Bocce Club Pizza?
Bocce Club Pizza is open from 10:00 AM to 11:00 PM Monday through Thursday and Sunday, and from 10:00 AM to midnight on Fridays and Saturdays.
What is special about Bocce Club Pizza's recipe?
Bocce Club Pizza uses a unique pizza recipe developed by the founder and emphasizes fresh, natural ingredients including 100% whole milk mozzarella and hand-stretched dough made daily.
How can I view the menu or place an order online at Bocce Club Pizza?
You can view the menu and place orders online at https://bocceclubpizza.com/menu/#.
What type of cuisine does Bocce Club Pizza offer?
Bocce Club Pizza offers pizza and Italian cuisine.
Can you tell me more about Bocce Club Pizza's history?
Bocce Club Pizza was started by Dino Pacciotti in 1946 after discovering a pizza oven in the basement of the Bocce Club on Hickory St in Buffalo, and later moved to Bailey Ave in Amherst in 1959 near UB South campus.
What nearby places can I visit before or after dining at Bocce Club Pizza?
Nearby places include Spa Envious for beauty services, O'Connell & Company theatre for live performances, and Windermere Park for outdoor activities.
Is there a theatre close to Bocce Club Pizza where I can enjoy a show?
Yes, O'Connell & Company theatre is nearby, offering theatrical productions and concerts that you can enjoy before or after your meal.
Where can I find wellness and spa services near Bocce Club Pizza?
Spa Envious and Voluptuous Nail Resort, both nearby, offer beauty and spa services to relax and pamper yourself around your visit to Bocce Club Pizza.
Are there any community centers near Bocce Club Pizza for family activities?
Yes, the Boys & Girls Club Of Buffalo and Eggertsville Youth and Community Center are close by, providing community programs and services that families might find useful when visiting the area.