Customers frequently praised the pizza as delicious and among the best in town, with specific mentions of the variety and freshness of ingredients.
Service Issues
Several reviews highlighted inconsistent service, including long wait times for food and instances of staff being inattentive or rude.
Atmosphere
The restaurant is described as having a welcoming atmosphere, though some customers noted issues with seating and cleanliness.
Pricing Concerns
Some customers felt that the prices were high relative to the portion sizes and quality, leading to mixed feelings about value.
MR
Monte Rutledge
5 days ago
4.0
The pizza is good, different than most places in town. There’s room for improvement, especially with the price. Two medium pizzas will run you $40 easy, no sides, no drinks, just 2 medium pizzas.
They have a dedicated app that is easy to use and works well. If you use Door Dash instead, pay attention. Door Dash is cheaper by about a dollar a pizza (odd) however, you have to pay close attention or your order won’t be correct. On DD, for example, if you try to order a Mediterranean pizza, it defaults to the New Mexican pizza (on DD app).
I recommend this place if you’re looking for good pizza and a good beer. It shines when you dine in not when you order out. The staff are great and very friendly. Beautiful waitresses, handsome waiters, smiles and laughter all around. I enjoy eating at the bar and find NYP to be a cool little hang-out when I want to chil solo or with a friend or two.
Parking sucks. But if you park in back, there’s always a space. It’s important to mention that NYP is moving to a new construction location across the street that is sure to be a hit and improvement.
Overall, this place deserves a solid 4/5. I eat pizza from here about 1 out of every 3-4 times I have pizza. If it were less cost or more food for the money, I’d eat pizza from here more often. But with Dion’s and all the other pizza places in town, NYP isn’t as strong a competitor as others for price, quality, atmosphere, and ease. It hits hard in some categories but not in others.
AS
Albert Sanchez
Feb 25, 2026
5.0
Get the Sicilian style crust! Comes out in a pan. It’s thicc! I started coming here 2 months ago and now I’ve brought my family. They love it. Also $2 Bud Lights along with other brews on tap.
SG
Sonya Grays
Feb 21, 2026
5.0
I loved the pizza the atmosphere and the service.
JL
Jeanne Libby
Feb 14, 2026
5.0
Food was delivered right on time and hot. Everything was delicious.
WB
William Bauma
Jan 25, 2026
5.0
Cooked to perfection, with smooth service and Beer from all around! The best people