America's Hometown Pizza Place™ since 1958. Home of the Original Thin and Original Pizza Buffet. Pizzas are hand-made daily with fresh dough. Choose from a variety of pizzas, pasta, salad, and desserts!
Multiple customers reported poor service, including long wait times and inattentive staff.
Food Quality
Inconsistent food quality was noted, with some praising the pizza while others described it as cold or lacking flavor.
Cleanliness Concerns
Several reviews mentioned cleanliness issues, particularly with silverware and food presentation.
Positive Experiences
Despite the negatives, many customers enjoyed the pizza and praised the friendly staff, especially during buffet visits.
TD
Todd Duplantis
Feb 11, 2026
1.0
Googled Pizza Inn, directed to a 3d party ordering system by Pizza Inn. 3rd party system isn't very clear. Ordered a pizza and toppings. Got a pizza with half toppings. Charged 34 dollars. Charged a $5 FEE for this 3rd party delivery svc, that pizza inn actually works for, because pizza inn delivered the pizza. At the same time a top was automatically added to the ticket. I call the restaurant. Talked with Sarah, the manager. Was told they're not responsible for 3rd party ordering systems, which is on their site. Was told that next time I should call directly. There won't be a next time. Get your crap straight and there should be a next time. This is now 2 times that THIS pizza inn has let me down. I will not let a 3rd one happen, and I will go out of my way to ensure people know what kind of scams this place is doing. FYI, this does not even taste like a 34 dollar pizza. I've had better totinos.
BE
Bryan Evjen
Jan 28, 2026
5.0
Make sure you get fresh out da oven pepperoni pizza! DA BEST!! Really good parmesan and house made ranch are delish!
CR
Clint Rogers
Jan 19, 2026
2.0
First and Foremost what you see in the commercial ISNT what you will get when you go in there. When I got there and told them I wanted the buffet they sat me at a table and gave me what I asked that I wanted to drink. They proceeded to do nothing else. So I had to stand up a few minutes later and ask what am I supposed to do because y'all told me to sit here. They were like well go get your food the plates are over there ... that would have been nice to know instead of telling me to sit down and then just walking away. When I went to CiCi's they would actually explain to go get your plates and what you want after asking what you want to drink. Not here. She told me to sit. Brought me my drink then went back to just chatting with another employee. I had high hopes thinking it would be like CiCis pizza with the BBQ pizza and different kinds. No. They had maybe 4 kinds (all variations of pepperoni and jalapeno) and you had to ask for whatever else you wanted and wait. Then the pizzas they had were dry and not good. I shouldn't have to pay $12 for pizza 🍕 that tastes like it's from the dollar store. I could have went and got a steak for $12 (yes just a steak). The pizza if I had to rate it out of 10 I'd give it 2 and the service a 3. I won't be going back. Anything is better than here for $12. I was literally in there maybe 6 minutes total. Sad. I ate 3 different slices and was like Nope this is garbage. If you have kids they have games that's their only plus. Other than that the food and service is subpar at best. This place is for families with kids who don't care how the food tastes since they have games to play but the food is garbage.
LW
Lexy Walker
Jan 10, 2026
3.0
It was ok. I loved in Salem Mo and the one there is so clean and fast paced and friendly. Id rather not come back to this one again.