Papa Johns Pizza

Reviews

• JK

  Jordan Kahley

  Aug 18, 2025
  1.0
  They said it was open until 2 am but they igorned my calls and said it was closes
• JW

  John Walter

  Jul 17, 2025
  1.0
  I absolutely love Papa Johns pizza. But this has got to be the worst chain. Everytime I get delivery either through papa or secondary it’s always wrong! They constantly forget the extra garlic sauces that I paid for and they ALWAYS forget the icing for the Oreo bites! And don’t blame it on uber eats! It’s on this franchise! Pick it up in person or don’t order at all.
• AS

  Asia Smalls

  Jun 1, 2025
  1.0
  SCAM! SCAM! SCAM! We placed an order over the phone for delivery, they transferred my call to a "secure" billing service but the initial payment did not go through, we tried again after transferring money from the original card we tried (so the money was absolutely there) to another bank account and that charge was unsuccessful as well although the money automatically came out of my account. It then transferred us to speak to someone. The person was extremely unhelpful and rude. He told us that the charge (in which by the way was in the amount of our order) was just an authorization charge and that we still needed to successfully pay in order to have our order fulfilled. We said how that didn't make sense and his only remedy was to transfer us to the store to have the order cancelled. We called the store and they said they couldn't help but told us to dispute the charge with our bank and place the order with them again. Essentially, the bank will refund us the money from their insurance and the establishment still keeps the money they claim they did not receive! DO NOT ORDER OR GIVE THEM YOUR CARD INFO
• AJ

  Albee J

  May 28, 2025
  5.0
  I haven't eaten Papa John's pizza for several years. I remember it was about ten years ago when I lived in Brooklyn. I would always order Papa John's pizza and could eat four slices at a time. After that, as I grew up and moved to another state, I never ordered Papa John's pizza again. Now I work in New Jersey, and there is a Papa John's not far from me. However, after reading the reviews, many of them were negative. Then I saw friends recommended that Domino's pizza was quite delicious. So I ordered Domino's before, gave it a try, and found that the price was nice and it tasted good too. Since I prefer New York style pizza, once I made a mistake and ordered the one with a very thick crust, which I really didn't like. Today, I ordered Papa John's pizza nearby to give it a try, and it turned out to be really delicious. I don't know why so many people gave it negative reviews, but I think it's really great.
• DS

  Desiree Sullivan

  Aug 27, 2023
  1.0
  Will not order from here ever again. Went to pick up my order, staff member said it’s in the oven. Waited another 15 minutes asked where my food was and they said oh we don’t have any wings so we didn’t make your order. This has happened several times. Go elsewhere bc they often cancel orders.

Frequently Asked Questions About Papa Johns Pizza