Made the Right Way. Every Day. There's a reason our bagels taste different--they're made the traditional way. At Manhattan Bagel, we give each bagel a dip in a kettle of boiling water, then bake them fresh each morning. That's how we get our authentic shiny bagels with a crispy, golden crust on the outside and that soft, satisfying chew inside. No shortcuts. Just real, authentic bagels made the way they were always meant to be. We kettle-boil our bagels to lock in that shine and crunch, then bake them fresh daily for a chewy, golden bite. No shortcuts, just the classic NY method - done right, right here, every day.
Numerous customers reported issues with incorrect orders, including missing items and wrong ingredients.
Customer Service
Feedback highlighted a mix of friendly staff and unprofessional behavior, with several customers experiencing rude service.
Food Quality
While some customers enjoyed the food, many expressed disappointment over portion sizes, pricing, and overall quality.
Cleanliness
Several reviews mentioned cleanliness issues, particularly in the dining area and bathrooms.
Pricing
Many customers felt the prices were too high for the quality and quantity of food received.
DB
Donald B
Dec 21, 2025
5.0
I popped in here for a quick bagel and coffee before shopping. The store was full of people at 10am on a Sunday. My toasted Asiago bagel with butter was very good and served right to my seat by a pleasant young man. Better than the bagel was the coffee. I’m a bit of a stickler with coffee. I am drawn to a dark roast coffee and this one was among the best in the area. Great job, MB.
CB
Coleb Bomb
Dec 20, 2025
2.0
Was given the wrong order. Was in situation where I couldn’t just go back to change order.
JP
Jr Pwi
Nov 30, 2025
1.0
Paid $8 dollars for a half a bacon strip and an egg. Compared to other bagel shops they ration like crazy. First time here and not coming back
MF
Mark Fuzia
Sep 21, 2025
1.0
Stop by for a bagel with butter. I don't think I got butter. See Pic. Don't think cutting prices on butter is a good way to treat your customers.
KB
Kate Berry
Sep 7, 2025
1.0
If I could give negative stars I would. I am baffled by the unprofessionalism at this bagel shop. I walk in with black jean shorts and a red hoodie (with the hood on), stand there waiting for someone to take my order. It’s been years since the last time I have been to this location so I was unaware of the change of the order station (to the middle register). A lady in a black t-shirt taps another lady in orange to tell her I was standing there. The lady in orange turns around and gasps and starts laughing. She says something in Spanish to the lady in black and she starts laughing while also pointing at me. Then the lady in orange tells me to order at the other counter. Am I a spectacle? Am I a ghost? Am I so invisible to you that you can’t see me standing here watching you laugh and point at me? To point and laugh at a customer was beyond rude, disrespectful and unbecoming of a chain bagel shop. To the ladies working that were laughing at me, this is not middle school so you should learn to act more professional in your work environment before you cause more trouble for other customers which will impact this business. As a cherry on top, to be charged over $10 for a plain bagel with egg and ham and a hash brown is way too expensive, especially for only one slice of ham! And $0.65 for butter? Ridiculous. This shop has made me feel unwelcome and I will not be returning. I will make sure to tell my friends and family to not visit such a rude and disrespectful place.
What payment methods are accepted at Manhattan Bagel?
Manhattan Bagel accepts debit cards, credit cards, and mobile NFC payments; cash is not required.
Is parking available at Manhattan Bagel?
Yes, free street parking and free parking lot options are available near Manhattan Bagel.
What are some nearby places to visit when I come to Manhattan Bagel?
Nearby places include Clean Way Laundry for laundry services, Tropical Smoothie Cafe for healthy smoothies, and Duane Edwards Salon for hair care needs.
Are there other dining options near Manhattan Bagel?
Yes, nearby dining options include Blimpie for sandwiches, Wingstop for chicken, and Taco Bell for Mexican fast food.
Can I combine a visit to Manhattan Bagel with shopping or other errands?
Absolutely! Nearby you can find Costco for wholesale shopping and gasoline, ShopRite supermarket for groceries, and several beauty salons like Star's Nails and Great Clips for personal care.