Numerous customers reported slow service, poor attitudes from staff, and incorrect orders, leading to a frustrating dining experience.
Food Quality
While some customers enjoyed the wings and other menu items, many complained about cold food, incorrect orders, and inconsistent quality.
Positive Staff Experiences
Several reviews highlighted exceptional service from specific staff members, indicating that there are capable employees who enhance the dining experience.
Cleanliness Concerns
Multiple reviews mentioned unsanitary conditions, including dirty tables and greasy floors, detracting from the overall atmosphere.
Value for Money
Customers expressed dissatisfaction with portion sizes and pricing, feeling that the value has decreased over time.
JT
Jorge Trigueros
Dec 23, 2025
1.0
Food was good, but the service was terrible.
Our server, Marlene, had a very poor attitude throughout the meal. I ate my entire meal without receiving the beverage I ordered. After waiting about 20 minutes, when she finally walked by and I asked about it, she said, “it’s coming out,” but it never arrived. I ended up drinking water from my wife instead.
It also took around 30 minutes just to receive our boxes and the check. The food was enjoyable, but the service seriously took away from the experience. Unfortunately, I wouldn’t return because of this. Also my friends told her the order wasn’t correct to which she replied “you have to be specific when ordering” although she never asked or repeated our order!
JS
Jessica Schulz
Dec 15, 2025
5.0
5 stars for Heather! She is absolutely amazing. Wings are always good, also.
JD
Jack Dankers
Dec 6, 2025
1.0
Placed an online order for 40 wings, 4 sides of fries, and 4 soft drinks. Got there to pick it up, and saw that my order bag was soaked in soda. There were no employees by the carry out register, so i went to the front to find someone to help me. No one came up to help, so after a moment i went back to the carry out area, and my order was gone. After a few minutes, an employee asks if I am picking up an order. I say I am, and that the bag was taken away. He said they would remake my order, and that I would need to wait a few minutes. Eventually, my order comes out, and i take it and leave. Only later did I find out that my 4 sides of fries were not in the bag. I spent 25 minutes standing in the store waiting for my order to be remade, only for half of my order to not be included.
MM
mike mags
Dec 1, 2025
3.0
Just placed an order for delivery. Ordered 15 traditional wings, received 15 boneless and paid full price for traditional. Probably wont order again with no way to get my money back
Frequently Asked Questions About Buffalo Wild Wings
What type of food does Buffalo Wild Wings in West Windsor offer?
Buffalo Wild Wings offers award-winning Buffalo, New York-style wings with 26 sauces and seasonings to choose from.
Where is Buffalo Wild Wings located in West Windsor, NJ?
It is located at 3465 US-1, West Windsor, NJ 08540, USA.
What are the operating hours of Buffalo Wild Wings in West Windsor?
They are open from 11:00 AM to midnight Monday through Thursday, and on Friday through Sunday they open 24 hours from midnight to 1:00 AM and then again from 11:00 AM to midnight.
Is Buffalo Wild Wings in West Windsor currently open?
No, the business status is listed as not closed.
How can I contact Buffalo Wild Wings in West Windsor?
You can reach them by phone at +1 609-803-3323.
Does Buffalo Wild Wings have an official website for the West Windsor location?
Yes, their website URL is https://www.buffalowildwings.com/locations/us/nj/west-windsor/3465-us-1/sports-bar-1420/
What kind of establishment is Buffalo Wild Wings in West Windsor?
It is a chicken wings restaurant, sports bar, takeout restaurant, and general restaurant.
Are there other Buffalo Wild Wings locations nearby this West Windsor restaurant?
Yes, there are other Buffalo Wild Wings nearby categorized as chicken restaurants, sports bars, and pubs.
What automotive services or dealerships are near Buffalo Wild Wings in West Windsor?
Near Buffalo Wild Wings, there are several automotive-related places including Drivesy of Princeton, Princeton MINI, Holman GO, and Service Center - Holman GO.
What are some nearby places where customers can get a coffee or breakfast before visiting Buffalo Wild Wings?
Customers can visit nearby spots like Dunkin' Donuts or WFM Coffee Bar at Whole Foods Market for coffee or breakfast before their visit.