Many customers praised the freshness and deliciousness of the meats, sandwiches, and prepared foods, although some noted inconsistencies in portion sizes and quality.
Customer Service
Feedback on staff interactions was mixed; while some customers highlighted friendly and helpful service, others reported rudeness and unprofessional behavior from certain employees.
Pricing
Several reviews mentioned high prices, with some customers feeling that the quality did not justify the cost, while others believed the prices were reasonable for the quality offered.
Cleanliness
The store was generally described as clean and well-organized, contributing positively to the shopping experience.
NZ
No-Panic- Zone
Jan 6, 2026
1.0
Bought some meat their that smelled so bad, and the expiration date was on the date I purchased it, and the person at the counter was trying their hardest to convince me that was the date it was packaged. Made absolutely NO sense, and got my money back..
DD
Dylan
Dec 23, 2025
1.0
Prices are insane! Got the same amount of meat from another local butcher and paid way less for honestly better quality meat as well.. people just like this place because its all they know..trust me branch out.. you will find a much much better bang for your buck. Staff was not friendly eaither... a woman behind the deli counter got off the phone with a customer then started talking bad about that customer to another employee.. not professional at all
MS
M S
Dec 23, 2025
1.0
One of the butchers was extremely rude.Made it seem like an inconvenience to help me out. All I was doing was picking up an order nice and simple, and for the money they charge.You would think their staff would be a little more friendly, no one knows what they're doing.They sent me 3 different people just to ask.Where's my order. And then I get this extremely rude guy, no thanks.. Me and my family's been coming here for years.You will never see us again.There's a much more friendly place on Fisher.
And it'll charge an arm and a leg and food is outstanding
AT
Abel theGuru
Dec 10, 2025
5.0
Well priced and friendly staff. Overall awesome place.
AT
Andrew Tobias
Dec 7, 2025
5.0
Very friendly and helpful staff.great prices and food selection.they have fresh meats and vegetables and other goods .they have package specials with all kinds of meats in it .
Frequently Asked Questions About Luigi's Deli, Butcher Shop & Catering
What types of events does Luigi's cater?
Luigi's caters a diverse range of events, accommodating everything from intimate family gatherings to large-scale corporate functions. Our catering services are suitable for various occasions including birthdays, weddings, and office parties.
Do you offer custom meat cuts?
Indeed, our butcher shop provides a custom meat-cutting service. Customers can specify their preferred cuts, and we'll prepare the meat fresh to their exact specifications.
What meals are available at the deli?
Our deli offers a comprehensive menu serving breakfast, lunch, and dinner every day. The selection includes a variety of options from sandwiches to hot meals, ensuring there's a suitable choice for every customer.
What types of meats do you carry?
We stock an extensive range of meats including filet mignon, our signature house-made sausages, and organic options. For the most up-to-date information on our current inventory, we encourage customers to contact us directly or visit our store.
What types of events does Luigi's Deli, Butcher Shop & Catering cater?
They cater a wide range of events including intimate family gatherings, large corporate functions, birthdays, weddings, and office parties.
Does Luigi's offer custom meat cuts?
Yes, their butcher shop provides custom meat-cutting services allowing customers to specify their preferred cuts prepared fresh to their specifications.
What meals are available at Luigi's deli?
Their deli serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner daily, featuring a variety of sandwiches, hot meals, and options for every customer.
What types of meats are carried at Luigi's butcher shop?
They stock a wide range of meats including filet mignon, signature house-made sausages, and organic options, with inventory available by contacting or visiting the store.
What are the operating hours of Luigi's Deli, Butcher Shop & Catering?
They are open Monday through Saturday from 7:00 AM to 7:00 PM, and Sunday from 7:00 AM to 5:00 PM.
What payment options does Luigi's accept?
Luigi's accepts American Express, Apple Pay, cash, Discover, MasterCard, and Visa.
Which languages are spoken at Luigi's Deli, Butcher Shop & Catering?
They offer services in English, Spanish, Italian, and American Sign Language to assist a diverse customer base.
What nearby dining options can customers visit near Luigi's?
Customers can try Midtown Pizzeria and LT's Pizzeria for pizza, Best Food In Town for Asian cuisine, or Quoney's - a Taste of "the South" for southern-style food—all located nearby and great choices before or after visiting Luigi's.
Are there nearby automotive services near Luigi's to assist customers?
Yes, nearby Mike's Riverside Auto (tire shop and automotive retail) and Brooks Auto Repair are available to customers needing automotive help during their visit to Luigi's.
What community and family services are accessible near Luigi's?
Customers with families can find South Toms River Elementary School, Kids Growing Early Learning Center, and Somewhere Special Day Care nearby, helpful for parents visiting or shopping at Luigi's.