Many customers reported poor service, with rude staff and incorrect orders being common complaints.
Product Quality
Several reviews highlighted issues with the quality of ice cream, including underfilled Blizzards and incorrect flavors.
Friendly Atmosphere
Despite service issues, some customers praised the friendly demeanor of certain staff members and the welcoming environment.
Pricing Concerns
Customers expressed dissatisfaction with pricing, noting that the value for money was lacking compared to other locations.
Operational Issues
There were complaints about slow service, especially during busy times, and problems with the drive-thru speaker.
KP
Kinjal Patel
Oct 27, 2025
5.0
Nice
LM
Leanne Moss
Sep 18, 2025
1.0
Drove out of our way to go here. Showed up at 9:50 pm and they literally shut the lights out on us at the drive through window. Completely rude and unacceptable.
RH
Ronald Hoffman
Aug 29, 2025
5.0
Cool, refreshing & deliciously enjoyable selections will make you return again for more treats for your taste buds.
NM
Nicole Mullen
Aug 24, 2025
1.0
This Dairy Queen on Route 23 in Wantage is the stingiest place in the area. I paid $6.34 for a small Reese’s Blizzard and got choc ice cream with maybe three crumbs of peanut butter cup. It’s like they’re scooping straight out of their own Halloween bucket. You don’t get a Blizzard here you get a cup of ice cream….Absolute joke! If you want a stacked blizzard, go to West Milford Dairy Queen on Route 23.
XV
Ximena Frigerio Valdivia
Jul 26, 2025
1.0
Ice cream parlor with 9, yes! Nine! Flavor to choose for a cone ice cream?