EARLY AMERICAN TAVERN

Reviews

• RH

  Rob Hamilton

  Apr 3, 2026
  1.0
  My girlfriend orders a calzone, her son orders a hamburger, and I order the salmon. And we had one app. The waitress wrote nothing down. Later, the burger and calzone come in a relatively timely fashion. No salmon. The waitress comes back 10 minutes later to ask how things are going...doesn't even acknowledge me (waiting for the salmon). The waitress comes back another 10 minutes later to refill drinks and still doesn't acknowledge me (still waiting for the salmon). My gf tells the waitress (in a kind way to point out the obvious) that she's not really eating her calzone because she's waiting for my salmon to come out so we can eat together. The waitress still offers no acknowledgement. Another 10 minutes later the waitress flies by and mumbles that the salmon is coming. Another 10 minutes later, my gf's son is done with his undercooked burger, my gf is done with her calzone (shout out here... it was really good), and the waitress arrives with my undercooked salmon and overcooked rice. She then asks me if I wanted to put that salmon dinner in a go-to box. Seriously? Then why go out? Another 10 minutes later, when she comes back, I respectfully told her that the salmon was undercooked (it was really bad), the burger was undercooked, the rice was overcooked, and of course I didn't get to have dinner with my gf and her son on this very special night. So, I think she's actually going to make things right....she says I shouldn't have to pay for the salmon and that she'll take it off the bill. Note: I never asked for this, I don't ask for freebies. But that gesture would go a long way. 10 minutes later, she brings the $70 check. The $24 salmon was not removed.....only $2.50 was subtracted from the bill. And she never came back.....
• MT

  Mike Trunzo

  Mar 23, 2026
  1.0
  Might wanna answer the phone
• KH

  kris hakes

  Mar 2, 2026
  5.0
  Great food and awesome music
• WF

  Welcome Family and Friends

  Feb 23, 2026
  5.0
  I had the special tonight Beef Straganoff. The meat was cooked to my preference and the entire dish was amazing. The beef was so tender and the sauce was amazing. Stop in.
• YY

  Yvonne

  Feb 22, 2026
  3.0
  Food is good, portions small considering they were dinner entre and wait was long. Prime rib was mostly fat. Service was excellent, and cordial atmosphere.