Mixed reviews on food quality; some customers praised the hoagies while others noted issues with portion sizes and stale bread.
Service Issues
Frequent complaints about incorrect orders and slow service, with some customers reporting unprofessional behavior from staff.
Pricing Concerns
Many customers feel the prices are too high for the quality and portion sizes received.
Cleanliness
Several reviews highlighted the cleanliness of the store, particularly the bathrooms.
Customer Experience
While some customers had positive experiences with friendly staff, others reported rude service and feeling ignored.
CP
Colour Printing
5 days ago
5.0
Sandwiches great as always but you must try the new fries!!
GP
Grace Parris
5 days ago
2.0
The sharp italian had barely any cheese, and when I opened it, all the toppings came flying out. The worst I ever had for the amount of money I should of just went to wawa. I would have got a full piece of cheese.Sharp Italian meat to chesse ratio is crazy it was like 5 crumbles of sharp provolone.
MM
Michael
Nov 21, 2025
2.0
The cheesesteak was disappointing. Probably my fault for not sticking with a hoagie at a hoagie place. Ratios were all off. Very light on the meat, packed with half cooked fried onions. And then the $5+ fries were half full.
NG
Nicholas Gkionis
Oct 21, 2025
3.0
Primo’s is a south jersey staple and even though it looks like a jersey mikes I prefer jersey mikes honestly. The italian was your standard italian. Good solid freshly cut sub or shall I say hoagie. The turkey sandwich was also solid but nothing stuck out to me about this place. Glad I tried it out but I have it at 3 stars. Not dying to go back.
CR
Celeste Romero
Oct 17, 2025
5.0
Primo's hoagies are the absolute best in NJ! The amount of meat, cheese and anything else you get on it is worth every penny!
What are the dine-in hours for PrimoHoagies in Sicklerville?
PrimoHoagies in Sicklerville is open for dine-in from 10:00 AM to 9:00 PM Monday through Thursday, 10:00 AM to 10:00 PM on Friday and Saturday, and 10:00 AM to 8:00 PM on Sunday.
Does PrimoHoagies offer delivery and pickup services?
Yes, PrimoHoagies offers in-store pickup, standard delivery, and same-day delivery services.
Where is PrimoHoagies located?
PrimoHoagies is located at 581 Berlin Cross Keys Rd, Sicklerville, NJ 08081, USA.
Can I place an order online for PrimoHoagies?
Yes, you can place an order online at https://order.primohoagies.com/.
What types of payment does PrimoHoagies accept?
PrimoHoagies accepts American Express, Apple Pay, Cash, Discover, MasterCard, Samsung Pay, and Visa.
Does PrimoHoagies have a mobile app for ordering?
Yes, there is an Android app available on Google Play and an iOS app available on the Apple App Store for PrimoHoagies.
Are there any nearby places of interest near PrimoHoagies in Sicklerville?
Yes, nearby places include Fuel Fitness gym, Hollywood Tans beauty salon, Nick's Pizza restaurant, and Dunkin' coffee shop.
Is there a fitness center near PrimoHoagies where customers can work out before or after dining?
Yes, Fuel Fitness gym is located near PrimoHoagies and is a convenient spot for customers wanting to exercise before or after their meal.
Are there other dining options close to PrimoHoagies in Sicklerville?
Yes, nearby dining options include Nick's Pizza, Shasha's Creole Kitchen (Haitian and Caribbean cuisine), Wingstop for chicken wings, and McDonald's.
Can customers visit nearby businesses like beauty salons or nail salons when they come to PrimoHoagies?
Yes, customers can easily visit nearby beauty-related businesses such as Hollywood Tans tanning and beauty salon, and MK Nails nail salon before or after dining at PrimoHoagies.