At Manhattan Bagel®, we wake up at 3am every morning to start your day with a smile and a full belly. Our NY-style bagels are boiled and baked fresh every day. We fire up our grills to bring you fresh-cracked eggs, sizzling bacon, and made-to-order sandwiches.
Customers praised the freshness and taste of bagels and breakfast sandwiches, but there were complaints about inconsistent quality and some items being served cold or undercooked.
Customer Service
Many reviews highlighted excellent customer service, with staff being friendly and accommodating, although some customers reported rude interactions and poor handling of complaints.
Pricing
Several customers noted that prices are on the higher side compared to competitors, with some feeling that the value does not match the cost due to portion sizes and quality.
Cleanliness
The establishment was generally described as clean, with some customers appreciating the hygiene practices observed by staff.
Variety
The menu offers a wide selection of bagels and breakfast items, which customers found appealing.
AM
A M
Oct 13, 2025
5.0
I went there for a late brunch. I got cinnamon raisin bagel toasted with cream cheese. It was delicious they were closing and still insisted on waiting on me, which I thought was great customer service. Most places would’ve said we’re closed, but they did not deny the service. I will definitely be back. Thanks for the great service.
DW
doozy wend
Sep 20, 2025
5.0
The Best Freshest Bagels You Can Have Great Place and Great Staff
ZW
Zara Rose Wilson
Aug 5, 2025
5.0
Great experience! Good food nice staff! 👍
RV
Richard “Army Veteran”
Aug 3, 2025
5.0
Bagels 🥯 in the morning are warm and fresh. Friendly and fast service. Great place for a quick bite and tasty bagel. Thank you
CP
Carmeleta Pestano
Aug 3, 2025
1.0
Wished I could do zero star...the sign states "free coffee with hot breakfast sandwich". The owner decided to let us know as we are cashing out that the free coffee is not available on weekends. See the photo with nothing mentioned that free coffee with hot sandwich purchase is not available on weekends. FALSE ADVERTISING
What are the operating hours of Manhattan Bagel in Sayreville, NJ?
Manhattan Bagel is open every day from 6:00 AM to 2:00 PM.
Where is Manhattan Bagel located?
Manhattan Bagel is located at 881 Main St, Sayreville, NJ 08872, USA.
What types of food and beverages does Manhattan Bagel offer?
Manhattan Bagel offers New York-style bagels, breakfast sandwiches, deli sandwiches, coffee, tea, muffins, cold brew, and catering services.
Can I order from Manhattan Bagel online?
Yes, you can order online quickly and easily through their website at https://www.manhattanbagel.com/order-now/.
Does Manhattan Bagel offer takeout and delivery services?
Yes, Manhattan Bagel offers takeout, delivery, and in-store pickup options.
Is there parking available at Manhattan Bagel?
Yes, there is free street and lot parking available near Manhattan Bagel.
What are some popular specialty sandwiches at Manhattan Bagel?
Popular specialties include the Original Bagel Classic Breakfast Sandwich, Nova Lox with Cream Cheese, Farmhouse Breakfast Sandwich, and the Smokehouse Brisket Egg Sandwich.
How can I find Manhattan Bagel if I'm visiting nearby places like La Rosetta Cafe or Main Street Liquors?
Manhattan Bagel is conveniently located near La Rosetta Cafe and Main Street Liquors on Main Street in Sayreville, making it easy to visit before or after enjoying these nearby spots.
Are there convenient amenities near Manhattan Bagel for visitors, such as pharmacies or salons?
Yes, nearby amenities include Main Street Specialty Pharmacy, Lash & Beauty Lounge, and Be Be Nails, allowing visitors to combine errands or enjoy beauty services alongside a meal.
What entertainment or leisure options are close to Manhattan Bagel?
Nearby leisure spots include My Key Spot concert venue and Mima Create and Play, a playground and zoo, perfect for a fun outing before or after your visit.