Mixed reviews on food quality; some dishes praised for flavor while others criticized for being bland or poorly prepared.
Service
Service received positive remarks for friendliness and attentiveness, but some customers reported issues with order accuracy and responsiveness.
Atmosphere
The restaurant has a warm and inviting atmosphere, though some noted cleanliness issues and a lack of climate control.
Value
Customers expressed concerns about portion sizes and pricing, with some feeling the meals were overpriced for the quality received.
Authenticity
Several reviews questioned the authenticity of the Caribbean cuisine, with some customers feeling it did not meet their expectations.
NP
Natalie Page
Nov 7, 2025
4.0
Good food, good portions, and good prices, but not authentic. Too mild to be considered Jamaican.
BR
Britney Rivera
Oct 27, 2025
3.0
If you come late in the day, it looks like an abandoned restaurant. When my family first pulled up, it looked like it was closed and we would have turned around if it wasn't for that SMALL DIM open sign.
The service was okay, but it seems like there was a very small selection and lonely atmosphere all together. It doesn't seem to get alot of business and I now know why...the food.
I had the Chili salmon. I had the last piece apparently and it was okay...but the rice was wierd and had an awful after taste. But the salmon was okay. The rice and beans were okay and the ox tail was okay.
I wouldn't come back but I don't regret trying something new.
JJ
Jon
Oct 14, 2025
5.0
A lot of tasty food to choose from!
EC
Eric Chii
Oct 3, 2025
1.0
The food tasted like it had been sitting there for days. The oxtail and jerk chicken were dry and bland, the plantains were hard and portion size was underwhelming-hardly any meat. Completely not worth the price. Extremely disappointed.
PH
Professor Hablawi
Sep 6, 2025
5.0
Delicious food, sweet people working the counter. The restaurant inside needs to have climate control; it is a bit too warm in there, so it is hard to sit inside.
Frequently Asked Questions About Hibiscus Island Grille - Randolph
What are the general operating hours of Hibiscus Island Grille - Randolph?
Hibiscus Island Grille - Randolph is open Monday through Saturday from 11:00 AM to 8:00 PM on most days, with extended hours on Friday and Saturday until 9:00 PM. The restaurant is closed on Sundays.
When is Hibiscus Island Grille - Randolph available for delivery services?
Delivery is available Monday through Saturday starting at 11:00 AM until 7:30 PM on weekdays, with Thursday until 8:00 PM and Friday and Saturday until 8:30 PM. The restaurant is closed for delivery on Sundays.
Does Hibiscus Island Grille - Randolph offer in-store pickup?
Yes, Hibiscus Island Grille - Randolph offers in-store pickup as one of their pickup and delivery services.
What are the takeout hours at Hibiscus Island Grille - Randolph?
Takeout is available Monday through Thursday from 11:00 AM to 8:00 PM, Friday and Saturday from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM, and the restaurant is closed on Sundays for takeout.
What type of cuisine does Hibiscus Island Grille - Randolph specialize in?
Hibiscus Island Grille - Randolph specializes in Caribbean and Jamaican cuisine, offering gluten-free and vegetarian options. It also features a bar and grill with live music.
Where is Hibiscus Island Grille - Randolph located?
It is located at 1594 NJ-10, Randolph, NJ 07869, United States.
What is the price range of dining at Hibiscus Island Grille - Randolph?
The dining price range at Hibiscus Island Grille - Randolph is considered to be moderate (Price Range TWO).
Are there any nearby golf or sports recreational facilities close to Hibiscus Island Grille - Randolph?
Yes, Clubhouse Golf Center and Grille, a golf course and sports venue, and Randolph Driving Range are located nearby, making the restaurant a convenient spot for a meal after golfing or sports activities.
What barbecue restaurants are near Hibiscus Island Grille - Randolph for visitors to explore?
Nearby barbecue spots include American Heroes Smokehouse and Red White & Que LLC, offering additional dining options for those interested in barbecue cuisine near Hibiscus Island Grille.
Which banks are located near Hibiscus Island Grille - Randolph, helpful for customers needing banking services?
TD Bank and Valley Bank are close to Hibiscus Island Grille - Randolph, convenient for customers who may want to handle banking tasks before or after dining at the restaurant.