Many customers praised the freshness and quality of the sushi, with specific mentions of excellent fish and unique rolls, while some expressed disappointment with salty or bland dishes.
Service Experience
Feedback on service was mixed; while some found staff friendly and attentive, others reported slow service and issues with order accuracy, particularly regarding food allergies.
Atmosphere
The restaurant's ambiance received positive remarks, with many appreciating the clean and pleasant dining environment, although some noted issues with the host's demeanor.
Value for Money
Several reviews indicated that while the food quality was high, some customers felt the prices were on the higher side, leading to mixed feelings about overall value.
Allergy Awareness
There were significant concerns regarding the restaurant's handling of food allergies, with one customer reporting a serious incident that raised safety issues.
SB
Sammy Berger
Oct 29, 2025
4.0
If we only came here once, it would have been 5 stars. Upon second visit and trying more of the menu, I have to knock it down to a 4.
The good: The crispy spicy tuna appetizer was great. The Snow Queen halibut was absolutely incredible. The fish quality in the sushi is high across the board.
The less-good: I ordered a signature maki (the Ice and Fire) and did not like it. The Salmon Mentai was way too salty. The tofu skewer's breading was soggy.
At this price point, one of my criteria for 5-star is that I can order anything off the menu - and even if I assumed I wouldn't like it, the chef would be good enough to change my mind. This doesn't meet that bar.
KS
Krysta Scharlach
Sep 29, 2025
5.0
Wonderful sushi, certified by a friend with Celiac to be safe. We went twice during our trip to Princeton, I got the sashimi combo the first time and the pan fried gyoza the second time. Both visits were lovely. Restaurant is BYOB only, there is no beer, wine, or cocktail menu - but they will bring you glasses and a bucket of ice!
WL
Won Lee
Sep 26, 2025
1.0
I waited food 55 min after ordered. the omakase sashimi was all salty. and some fish had smell and specially oyster. And I am writing down in the bathroom right after came back home with water poopoo. I guess it is because of oyster. Trust me, I am asian I ate so many different sashimi in my whole life even in korea, Japan, hongkong, china,, macau, thiland...and I really cannot say all fish quality of this restaurant was acceptable.
JG
Juan Gordon
Sep 23, 2025
5.0
My partner and I found this place 5 years ago, and it’s been a date night staple for us since. The staff is friendly and so accommodating, doesn’t matter when we go, lunch or dinner there’s always a great vibe and it helps that it’s in one of our favorite cities in NJ. We take our son with us now and he loves it too. We’re not going to gate keep this place, if you’re looking at reviews and you’re on the fence, consider this the defining review that will get you to go. Bring a bottle of wine, order the summer roll and the scampi, and tell them Juan sent you. You won’t be disappointed.
AA
Arina
Aug 24, 2025
5.0
Everything was fresh and delicious — from the miso soup to the sushi and chicken teriyaki. I really enjoyed it and can only give good recommendations!
Frequently Asked Questions About Elite Five Sushi & Grill
What are the operating hours of Elite Five Sushi & Grill?
Elite Five Sushi & Grill is open Monday and Wednesday through Sunday from 11:30 AM to 9:00 PM. It is closed on Tuesdays.
Does Elite Five Sushi & Grill offer delivery and takeout services?
Yes, Elite Five Sushi & Grill offers both in-store pickup and delivery services.
Can I place an order online for Elite Five Sushi & Grill?
Yes, you can view the menu and place an order online at https://elitefives.com/menu.
Where is Elite Five Sushi & Grill located?
It is located at 277 Witherspoon St, Princeton, NJ 08540, USA.
What type of cuisine does Elite Five Sushi & Grill specialize in?
Elite Five Sushi & Grill specializes in sushi, Japanese cuisine, seafood, Asian fusion, and offers vegetarian options.
Is curbside pickup available at Elite Five Sushi & Grill?
Yes, curbside pickup is available at Elite Five Sushi & Grill.
What is the price range at Elite Five Sushi & Grill?
The price range at Elite Five Sushi & Grill is moderate, classified as 'TWO'.
Are there any nearby fitness centers to Elite Five Sushi & Grill?
Yes, Princeton Fit Body Boot Camp, a gym offering sports and fitness instruction, is nearby and a great place to work out before or after dining.
What medical facilities are located near Elite Five Sushi & Grill?
Nearby medical facilities include Princeton Pain Management, Witherspoon Oral Surgery, and Princeton Medicine Physicians - Center for Digestive Health Princeton, which may be convenient for medical appointments before or after your visit.
Are there any notable places to visit close to Elite Five Sushi & Grill?
Nassau Street Properties: Princeton Apartments, a local landmark and historical building, is close by. Additionally, The Meeting House, an American restaurant and bar, is a good spot to visit nearby.