Business Details
About
Italian Restaurant
Details
- DeliveryAvailable
- TakeoutAvailable
- Curbside pickupAvailable
Location
Hours
Reviews
4.3
322 reviews
5 stars
221
4 stars
46
3 stars
20
2 stars
11
1 star
24
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Food Quality
Customers frequently praised the delicious and authentic Italian food, with many highlighting specific dishes like the Penne Vodka and cannoli.
Service
While many reviews commended the attentive and friendly service, there were notable complaints about slow service and poor management during busy times.
Atmosphere
The restaurant is described as having a warm and inviting atmosphere, suitable for both intimate dinners and larger celebrations.
Catering and Events
Stefano's is highly recommended for hosting events, with many customers expressing satisfaction with the catering services and the ability to accommodate large groups.
Inconsistency
Some customers reported inconsistent experiences, particularly regarding food preparation and service speed, which affected their overall satisfaction.
- ARAnthony RufoDec 31, 20255.0Wonderful owners and staff with great food 👍👍
- TRTrish RoemerDec 28, 20255.0Love the little restaurant in the front. Delicious food, wonderful wait staff and friendly behind the counter. The food is amazing and always a pleasant experience
- LGLinda GannonDec 27, 20253.0The Stefanos online ordering system allowed me to order a dinner for Christmas Day to pick up on the 25th. Even confirmed the order with me online. Christmas day went to pick up order at restaurant. Restaurant closed! Upon calling today (Saturday) and explaining what happened that wrecked our Christmas dinner, they gave us a measly 10% off order we placed. My shrimp scampi had FIVE shrimp and more noodles than a human could eat in days. What?? We have eaten at this restaurant frequently over the years, but their careless attitude and lousy meal preparation will have us dining elsewhere.
- STSharon TantDec 27, 20255.0Picked up food for Christmas Eve. food was delicious.
- RRRingwoodDec 6, 20255.0My daughter had a large group of friends celebrating her birthday at Stefano’s, and the entire experience was wonderful. The owner worked closely with me to make sure the food and seating setup were exactly what we needed. He was transparent about everything, incredibly accommodating, and truly attentive to making the night go smoothly. The girls loved the food, especially the Penne Vodka, which was the girls favorite. Cesar salad they said was delicious. The service was top-notch from start to finish, and the girls left happy, full, and already talking about how great everything was. Highly recommend!
Frequently Asked Questions About Stefano's Restaurant
What are the regular dining hours for Stefano's Restaurant?
Stefano's Restaurant is open Tuesday through Saturday from 12:00 PM to 3:00 PM for lunch and from 4:30 PM to 10:00 PM for dinner. On Sunday, it is open from 3:00 PM to 8:41 PM. The restaurant is closed on Mondays.
Is Stefano's Restaurant open for takeout service?
Yes, takeout service is available Tuesday through Saturday from 11:30 AM to 9:45 PM, and Sunday from 3:00 PM to 8:41 PM. It is closed for takeout on Mondays.
Does Stefano's Restaurant offer delivery service?
Stefano's Restaurant offers delivery service from Tuesday through Saturday between 11:30 AM and 9:45 PM, and on Sunday from 3:00 PM to 8:41 PM. Delivery is not available on Mondays.
Can I pick up my order in-store at Stefano's Restaurant?
Yes, Stefano's Restaurant offers in-store pickup services for customers.
Where is Stefano's Restaurant located?
Stefano's Restaurant is located at 565 Rt 23 S, Pompton Plains, NJ 07444, United States.
What cuisines does Stefano's Restaurant specialize in?
Stefano's Restaurant specializes in Italian cuisine, including seafood, pasta, steaks, salads, vegetarian dishes, and desserts. It is also a family-friendly restaurant and offers catering services.
Where can I view the menu or place an order online for Stefano's Restaurant?
You can view the menu and place orders online at https://stefanosrestaurant.net/menu.
Are there other dining options near Stefano's Restaurant?
Nearby, you can find Stefano's Italian Fine Dining, Stefano's Ristorante, and Stefano's Pizzeria, which also serve Italian cuisine including pizza. These options provide more variety for Italian food lovers in the area.
What local businesses near Stefano's Restaurant offer beauty and spa services?
Nearby beauty and spa options include Polished by Holli Nail Suite, Lyndsie Victoria Beauty, Velvet & Mane, Nicole's Hair Studio, Genial Hut, Public Image Ltd The Salon, Monarch Beauty Lounge LLC, Mindbodyesthetics LLC, Salon Brugatto, and LJ's Nails Allure. They offer services such as hair styling, nail care, waxing, and massages.
Are there any local attractions or shops near Stefano's Restaurant worth visiting?
Yes, near Stefano's Restaurant you can visit the Martin Berry House, a local landmark and historical building. For shopping, there are thrift stores like The Goodwill Store and Goodwill NYNJ Store & Donation Center, as well as specialty shops like Dunkin' for coffee and Baskin-Robbins for ice cream.