Your local Pine Brook, NJ Bonefish Grill® specializes in hand-cut, wood-grilled specialties and locally crafted Partner Selection dishes made with the freshest, highest-quality ingredients. The restaurant offers a selection of classic and signature hand-crafted cocktails, using just-squeezed juices, edible garnishes, and house infusions in addition to offering a distinct list of wines, which are the perfect match for any food pairing. In Pinebrook on 46 west just before Hook Mountain Road
Customers frequently praised the food for being delicious and well-prepared, with standout dishes like Bang Bang Shrimp and Pan-Asian Butterfish receiving particular acclaim.
Service Experience
Service quality varied, with many customers highlighting exceptional servers like Tyler and Vianka, while some reported uncomfortable tipping practices and instances of inattentive service.
Ambiance
The restaurant's atmosphere was generally described as warm and inviting, although some customers noted issues with lighting and overall ambiance.
Management Issues
Several reviews mentioned negative experiences with management, including instances of disrespectful behavior towards staff, which impacted customer satisfaction.
Value for Money
While many customers felt the food was worth the price, some expressed concerns about portion sizes and perceived high prices relative to the quality.
VM
Vannetta Matthews
Nov 11, 2025
5.0
It was the 1st time my family and I visited this restaurant. Wow, I was very impressed everything was freshly made and delicious. All 5 of us give them 5 stars. The staff was very friendly, the bathroom was Cleaned, the seating was very nice, clean atmosphere. We really enjoyed ourselves and are planning our next outing.
RL
Roya Lotfi
Nov 5, 2025
5.0
Great service and food. Our server Vianka was so sweet and attentive. Atmosphere is really nice and cozy. This place is great for any day, but even better if you go when they’re having one of their specials usually on Tuesday or Wednesday. Killer deal for the amount and quality of food you get.
MM
matthew mclaughlin
Nov 4, 2025
3.0
Honestly the food was awesome. We did the two for $45 . Food outstanding . So much food we couldnt eat it all between the two of us.
Now I am NOT a fan Of the server bringing me a machine to pay on , Standing behind me Watching me click buttons and telling me oh There's going to be a question You need to answer after paying. This made me feel extremely uncomfortable and my date felt very uncomfortable watching the server standing right behind me. I could feel her breath on me while I was deciding if I should give her a tip. I was generous gave her a tip.
This made me very uncomfortable that the server, I felt basically held me hostage to give her a tip by standing behind me and staring/GLARING over my shoulder .
ThIs tipping culture needs to get some manners and respect their customers. Privacy is a thing .
Id much rather write my tip on a paper rather be suggested a 18% tip as the lowest minimum tip . Not all service requires a tip! This service definitely didnt deserve a 18% tip Especially if you're going to stand behind me while i pay and decide what I should tip..
If anyone should be tipped i would like the chef/cooks who made this meal to get tipped!
This experiencereally upset me . Im not going to be visiting this bonefish grill again
LM
Lana Maj
Oct 27, 2025
5.0
the best service i’ve ever experienced! i’m a bartender myself & Brian was amazing! highly recommend this place for din din & happy hour. the ahi tuna wonton crisps was absolutely the freshest tuna i’ve ever had. i’m not the biggest on raw food but 10/10. the drinks were nice and boozy! margarita connoisseur here, highly freaking recommended. shrimp toast was my mother in laws fav & the shrimp were so tender. if ya want seafood prepped in different ways, come hereeee! last thing to mention, if ya wanna be entertained, ask for brian :)
EH
Earl Haley
Oct 17, 2025
4.0
We started the evening with drinks — an Apple Martini for my wife and a Smoked Old Fashioned for me. Both were excellent, balanced, and well-prepared.
For appetizers, we had the Bang Bang Shrimp and the Tempura Crunch Sashimi Tuna. The tuna was very tasty and fresh, while the shrimp, though good, seemed to have a little less “bang” than I remember from past visits.
For entrées, my wife ordered the Scallops & Shrimp Scampi Pasta, and I went with the Pan-Asian Butterfish. Both dishes were flavorful, well-portioned, and beautifully presented.
But the star of the night was our waiter, Tyler R. He was outstanding — attentive without being overbearing, personable, and genuinely skilled at what he does. His personality really shines, and he turned what would’ve been a good meal into an excellent dining experience. I even overheard another table complimenting him on his service.
All in all, great food, solid portions, excellent drinks — and a waiter who truly elevated the night.
Does Bonefish Grill in Pine Brook accept reservations?
Yes, Bonefish Grill in Pine Brook accepts reservations and you can book them online via their reservation URL.
What are the brunch hours at Bonefish Grill Pine Brook?
Brunch is served only on Saturdays and Sundays from 11:00 AM to 3:00 PM. The restaurant is closed for brunch Monday through Friday.
When is happy hour available at Bonefish Grill in Pine Brook?
Happy hour is offered daily from 4:00 PM to 6:30 PM.
What types of payment does Bonefish Grill in Pine Brook accept?
Bonefish Grill accepts American Express, Cash, Check, Discover, Mastercard, and Visa payments.
Does Bonefish Grill offer takeout and delivery services?
Yes, the restaurant offers both in-store pickup and delivery services for your convenience.
What is the dress code at Bonefish Grill Pine Brook?
The dress code at Bonefish Grill is casual, making it a comfortable spot to enjoy your meal.
What kind of cuisine and specialties does Bonefish Grill Pine Brook offer?
Bonefish Grill specializes in hand-cut, wood-grilled seafood specialties and locally crafted dishes made with fresh, high-quality ingredients along with a selection of signature cocktails and wines.
Can I find Bonefish Grill near the Sea Level Aquarium or other nearby places?
Yes, Bonefish Grill is located nearby several places including the Sea Level Aquarium. You can combine a visit to the aquarium with dining at Bonefish Grill for a full day of fun and great food.
How can nearby places like Revolution Cycling Studio or Serenity Day Spa enhance my visit to Bonefish Grill?
You can enjoy a workout at Revolution Cycling Studio or relax at Serenity Day Spa before or after dining at Bonefish Grill, making for a well-rounded and enjoyable day in Pine Brook.
Are there other dining options near Bonefish Grill Pine Brook?
Yes, nearby dining options include mangia casa cucina (Italian restaurant), WOOD STACK Pizza Kitchen, and Amin's Shawarma & Grill offering diverse cuisine experiences.