Tony's Pizzeria

Reviews

• NB

  Nica Bellantuono

  2 days ago
  5.0
  ordered the salmon Caesar salad and it was really good. Everything tasted super fresh, the lettuce had a nice crunch, and the dressing wasn’t too heavy or overly creamy. The salmon was the best part though. It was cooked perfectly, really tender and flaky, with that soft, delicate texture where it just melts when you eat it. The flavor wasn’t overpowering either, it blended really well with the salad instead of taking over. Honestly, it just felt like everything was done right. Simple, fresh, and really satisfying without feeling too heavy. this is my go to order now.
• SP

  Stacey Pavelko

  Apr 20, 2026
  1.0
  Don't go here!! I ordered dinner to be delivered. I ordered at 5:11. It was supposed to be delivered by 6:01. I called at 6:05. I was told... I'm sorry, we had a problem. It will be there in 15-20. At 6:25 I called... Again... So sorry. It will be there in 5... At 6:45, I drove to Taco Bell drive thru. Delivery arrived at 6:51. The best I got was... Sorry... I looked at the food... The ravioli was so overcooked that it was inedible... Taco Bell was better
• NW

  Nancy Wingfield

  Apr 6, 2026
  5.0
  We are from Montréal, Canada, we were in vacation for easter week-end in Ironbound, to see New-York city and for an hockeygame at the Prudential center. We order a pizza from Tony's pizzeria, it was one of the best pizza we ever eat. We recommand Tony's pizza all the way! Hey people who live in the area of Tony's pizzeria, don't hesitate, you won't be disapointed! Order at this place! Robert and Nancy 😋🍕❤️
• MM

  Marius Monopoly

  Apr 2, 2026
  5.0
  I randomly selected this pizza joint as I was near Newark downtown but I wanted to try a local classic. I ordered my classic, sausage, mushrooms and green olives, OMG, thia pizza was so so good. The crust was perfectly seasoned and the ingredients were fresh and of high quality. I highly recommend it.
• MP

  Moon Child Pink

  Mar 28, 2026
  5.0
  Excellent pizza & fast service. Ordered right before closing & had our pizza delivered to the Holiday Inn at Newark international airport. The service was fast & the pizza was excellent. The delivery person let us know when he was 5 minutes away & we met him in the lobby. Very happy to have found Tony's pizza as it was delicious. Will definitely be ordering again the next time we are in Newark.