Many customers praised the pizza for its delicious taste, fresh ingredients, and authentic flavors, with specific mentions of unique offerings like the hot honey pepperoni and semolina crust.
Customer Service
Feedback on customer service was mixed; while some praised the friendly staff and quick delivery, others reported rude interactions and issues with order accuracy.
Delivery Issues
Several reviews highlighted problems with delivery times, including late arrivals and cold food, which negatively impacted the overall experience for some customers.
Consistency
There were mentions of inconsistency in food quality, with some customers experiencing great meals while others received subpar or burnt items.
RP
Rose Perez
4 days ago
5.0
hi,
I ordered food yesterday, and as in the past everything was delicious. I ordered for 5PM and delivered right on time.
Great food and service.
SM
Stephanie Mauge
Feb 21, 2026
5.0
I had a sausage with onions, peppers, pepperoni and extra cheese , medium six slice pie delivered to my hotel. The pizza was hot, cheesy and delicious! I am glad that I ordered pizza from Tony’s Pizza!!
RO
Ryan OCallaghan
Feb 15, 2026
1.0
Delivery was made by a driver of the store. He must have dropped it en route and failed to tell me. I called the store and the girl on the line was useless and said she'd let the owner know and that they wouldn't replace it.
AS
Alexandra Suszko
Feb 14, 2026
5.0
The food and pizza is really very good here. I usually get take out but on occasion will pick up. The outside of the building is older which can be misleading but the interior has a modern/updated look and is very clean inside. There are other pizza places in the neighborhood but I've been disappointed by them. Tony's has the most authentic pizza in the area.
AD
Alex D
Jan 29, 2026
1.0
You can look at my review history and see that I never leave negative reviews, truly never. But the customer service (or lack thereof) here is deserving of it. Never received the food, after waiting two hours finally called only to be told that it was “next”, didn’t ask my name or my order so I assume she knew that based on my phone number? Then when I asked if the food was going to be cold being that it has been driving around for an hour, l she said “I don’t know”, and hung up. Was really looking forward to trying the food, but I should’ve read the reviews first.