Many customers praised the food, especially the pizza and Italian dishes, noting freshness and great flavors.
Service Issues
Several reviews highlighted inconsistent service, with some customers experiencing rudeness from management and slow response times during busy periods.
Atmosphere
The restaurant's atmosphere was generally described as welcoming and pleasant, with some noting the nice outdoor seating.
Pricing Concerns
Some customers felt the prices were high for the portion sizes and quality, leading to mixed feelings about value.
Positive Experiences
Despite some negative feedback, many customers expressed a strong desire to return, citing positive experiences with staff and overall enjoyment.
JW
Jayla White
4 days ago
5.0
This is the best pizzeria. The most friendliest staff. Great food and amazing pizza selection. Would definitely recommend this place to everyone
JH
James Hickey
6 days ago
1.0
This past Saturday night I walked over to Capisce to get a meatball parm, I've been getting that same order there for many years. I was doing work nearby, about three quarters of a mile away. When I walked back I found they had given me a chicken parm. How do you screw that up especially when the order was repeated back to me. I called, explained what happened, and said I'll be walking back to get my fixed order. It wasn't ready yet when I got back and I asked to speak to the owner to see if they would make up for it. The kid behind the counter came back and said we'll you're getting a free sandwich and laughed about it, I had brought back the chicken parm uneaten. I asked again to speak to the owner and after a minute or so the kid came back and said he was busy. BUSY??? To talk to a loyal customer about a screwed up order??? That's your damn job, to speak to your customers if there's an issue! The kid behind the counter again laughed and again said you're getting a free sandwich. They had already taken the chicken parm away and I said so you're making up for it by not charging for the sandwich I wanted? No he said, you're getting the chicken parm for free. I said you already took it back so how am I getting a free sandwich. By that time I had had enough. A month earlier a similar thing happened at Godfather in Morristown. They apologized, delivered the correct order, and credited my account. Capisce did neither, not even an apology. So a screwed up order, no apology, no compensation, owner too busy, and laughed at. I will never set foot in or order from them again! This is how they treat a many years loyal customer and a 64 year old Marine Veteran.
SG
Sandeep Grover
Aug 29, 2025
5.0
Loved it !!
BM
Barry Manalow
Aug 2, 2025
5.0
Great food, took the old man for dinner.
CF
Carole Flynn
Jul 28, 2025
5.0
Last week my husband, son and I had a Margarita large round pie and ate at the restaurant. It was outstanding. The no flop crust and the sweet tomato sauce, fresh cheese and basil made it! It's also a BYOB. Tonight we are getting take out - Grandma Square Pie. The staff are very hospitable.