Stella's 24 Hour Eatery

Reviews

• LS

  London Skittles

  Apr 5, 2026
  5.0
  My first time trying out this place. Good vibes only, they personally called and let me know one of my pizzas were unavailable at that time. I believed it was the philly steak one. That's ok it just proved to me how good the pizza is there. Was not disappointed at all. the meat lover was 💯. I ordered online and was ready for pickup when I got there. Nice and hot. Will return when I'm back in jc.
• FM

  F “Familie Melsungen”

  Apr 3, 2026
  5.0
  Super leckere Pizza! Wir halten da jedes Mal an wenn wir über New Jersey nach New York gehen. Das Personal ist sehr freundlich und das Preis-Leistungs-Verhältnis ist auch gut
• HR

  Honest Reviews

  Mar 29, 2026
  5.0
  Visited last year from UK, bossman kept me calling maharaja legend, top quality service and omg best garlic sauce and hot sauce, and from my experience it’s better than many of the famous places in New York that you have to queue up for. It’s been a year and I can smell and taste the food from Stella. It’s the staff who made me feel like home when I visited. Tourist friendly!
• MP

  M P

  Mar 19, 2026
  5.0
  One of the best pizza in downtown jersey. Next door in the corner at Pnc Bank 317 Grove was a diner when I was a kid. Used to go there with my dad and my cousin. Memories.
• RS

  Ross S

  Mar 1, 2026
  1.0
  I have witnessed something at your establishment more than once that was beyond disturbing and frankly nauseating. A few weeks ago, around midnight, while I was eating at a table, a visibly drunk woman stumbled in. She was loud, belligerent, and spewing racist slurs across the room. Instead of being stopped, she swaggered straight behind the pizza counter — into the food prep area — as if she owned the place. What happened next was revolting. She began grabbing at the staff, hugging them, trying to kiss them, putting her hands all over their faces and cheeks — hands that had just been waving around in the street and touching who knows what. Then, without washing her hands or being stopped, she reached over and started taking bites directly out of two or three pizzas that were sitting out, tearing at them with those same unwashed hands. Food that was meant for paying customers. What made it worse was that no one intervened. No one stopped her. The staff were giggling and entertaining her drunken, offensive rambling as if it were amusing. Meanwhile, she was contaminating food and violating basic hygiene standards right in front of everyone. The entire environment felt filthy, chaotic, and completely out of control. I was so uncomfortable and disgusted that I immediately walked out. A couple of nights before that, I saw the same woman doing the exact same thing. This time, I turned around at the door and left without even going in. The fact that I’ve seen this happen more than once makes it clear that this behavior is being allowed. She does not behave like a normal customer — she doesn’t sit down, she doesn’t order — she goes straight behind the counter every time. This is not only deeply unhygienic, it creates an unsafe and extremely unpleasant experience for other customers. Watching someone drunkenly manhandle staff and stick her hands and mouth into food being prepared for others is absolutely unacceptable.

Frequently Asked Questions About Stella's 24 Hour Eatery