Customers consistently praised the food for its authentic flavors, large portions, and freshness, with many highlighting specific dishes like birria tacos and mole sauce.
Service
While many reviews noted friendly and attentive service, there were also complaints about inconsistent service and issues with automatic gratuity charges.
Atmosphere
The restaurant's decor and ambiance received positive feedback, with many describing it as colorful and inviting, contributing to an enjoyable dining experience.
Pricing
Some customers felt the prices were high for the portion sizes and quality, with a few mentioning unexpected charges for extras.
AW
Alissa Walters
4 days ago
5.0
Highly recommend El Agave. Every time we come here the good never disappoints and it's hard to find a good safe place for my family to eat as we have a lot of food allergies. We have had absolutely no problems here and the food is consistently good. We keep coming back and they keep being delicious so come support this delicious restaurant!
CM
Chris Mennella
Dec 31, 2025
5.0
Fresh and authentic!
MM
Melissa Morello
Dec 30, 2025
5.0
Our favorite restaurant in the Boro. Everything is delicious. We’ve ordered many times and have never been disappointed. Great portion sizes as well.
DD
DaveT
Dec 9, 2025
4.0
Pretty good Mexican food.
JP
Jayraj Patel
Nov 17, 2025
5.0
Absolutely loved this place! The staff were incredibly welcoming, the food was exceptional, and the ambience truly transported us to the heart of Mexico. Every detail was thoughtfully curated to create an authentic and memorable experience. I wholeheartedly recommend this gem—100% satisfaction guaranteed!