Olivia's II Pizza and Pasta

Reviews

• AA

  Albert

  Jan 11, 2026
  5.0
  This place is awesome! John owner of Olivia’s # 2 in Eatontown is amazing. Recently had his Honey Bomb pizza & Chicken Parm rolls & it was delicious. Also all his cold & hot subs are made with more than enough meat & made with love. Delivery is always on time & if you decide to eat inside his place, you will get great service & place is always neat & clean. If you’re in the Eatontown area or neighborhood, I highly recommend this place. Enjoy everyone!
• AS

  Andrea Savino

  Jan 11, 2026
  5.0
  John Summers owner of Olivia's II in eatontown has very good specials at reasonable prices and plentiful portions the food is always hot and fresh I have never had a bad meal there and it is even hot on delivery everybody is always kind and friendly in the restaurant and his delivery people are always kind as well I recommend that you give this place a try you won't be disappointed
• JB

  John Bucchieri

  Jan 11, 2026
  5.0
  Ive have been a customer at Olivia 11 in Eatontown for a long time. Im the biggest critic when it comes to pizza and Italian dishes. Im a Brooklyn born Italian and know good food. Olivia uses all of the freshest ingredients and cook dishes to perfection. Even when I ask for something thats not on the menu they try to accommodate. I use them to cater hot and cold foods. Their heros are always prepared perfect with the right amount of cold cuts. I highly reccomend trying Olivia pizza and pasta in Eatontown. Their prices are very affordable. You will be hooked once you try their food.
• MA

  Mike A

  Jan 10, 2026
  5.0
  We had an amazing time at Olivia’s II. John is an amazing chef and host. The pizza was the best and we really appreciated the suggestion to have a round Grandma pizza to contrast with the square Honey Bomb. The Thai wings were phenomenal and the wrapped artichoke hearts were marvelously paired their special sauce. Fried calamari was spot on and John’s special red sauce is truly magical. Thanks so much for a great reunion dinner for our fam and can’t wait to stop by on our next trip to NJ!!
• AH

  Ashley Harvey

  Jan 8, 2026
  1.0
  This is very upsetting to wRite as Olivia’s two is definitely my favorite pizza in New Jersey. Today’s the last time we will ever be going there. The last time we ordered pick up, the older woman in the front was scolding a family because they just wanted slices and a salad and didn’t offer them a place to sit when they said they would’ve dined in if that was offered in the first place. Service is definitely been off the last six times we’ve been. Today, as my daughter was eating her cutie pie there was a black hair underneath the cheese. I informed the waitress of this matter and she took the plate immediately away and came back and only offered 20% off the pizza through the receipt down on the table and left and said nothing further. We are very good customers, sometimes even offering up to 50% tip. So this is extremely sad to say we will not return

Frequently Asked Questions About Olivia's II Pizza and Pasta