Customers consistently praised the food, especially the pizza, pasta, and chicken dishes, highlighting freshness and generous portions.
Service
The staff received numerous compliments for being friendly, attentive, and accommodating, contributing to a welcoming atmosphere.
Community Engagement
The owner and staff are noted for their support of local events and schools, enhancing their reputation in the community.
Consistency
Many reviews emphasized the consistent quality of food and service, with customers expressing loyalty and frequent visits.
Atmosphere
The restaurant is described as having a cozy and family-friendly vibe, making it a popular choice for dining in and takeout.
JM
Jackie Maguire
Nov 14, 2025
5.0
We love Olivia’s ll! It’s our go to pizza place and they also have great dinners and wraps! John the owner is always supporting the community/schools as well!
LH
Luis Hernandez
Nov 12, 2025
5.0
Their chicken wings were excellent. Crisp on the outside, tender inside, and seasoned just right. The sauce had a clean flavor that did not drown the meat. Portion size was generous, and everything arrived hot. It hit the spot so well I almost forgot it was takeout.
TR
Therese Rosell
Nov 9, 2025
5.0
5/5 Ordered a chicken parm roll at Olivia's and was amazed! Super filling and perfect for those of us who love pizza. The staff were really kind as well. I'll definitely be back whenever I'm in the area.
CM
Christopher Marino
Nov 7, 2025
5.0
Available on Friday's, the shrimp scampi slice is a must-have. Pair it with a slice of the amazing honey bomb slice (hot honey & pepperoni on a everything bagel crust) and you're all set. Pizza is outstanding!
BM
Bruno Molino
Oct 30, 2025
5.0
I rarely write reviews, but John's pizza at Olivia's in Eatontown is so good that I couldn't resist. I'm 100% Italian, so I am pretty particular about pizza, especially the sauce. This is the best pizza I have ever had, and it's my go to when I get the craving. See my posted picture. This is not a produced advertisement picture, but the actual slice I just had today. Crust is perfect, no flop, with the perfect crunch. Sauce is excellent, nothing more to say. I always get the large with mushrooms, eggplant, roasted red peppers, and spinach, with extra sauce. If that ever comes as an option, they should call it the Bruno. My usual order is a large house salad with extra chicken, to be health conscious, and then the pizza to indulge. It's heavenly. The rest of the food is also excellent, but I have to get a pizza when I go. Check it out, highly recommend. You won't regret it.