Brand Certified
Cogman's Creek
4.6(208 reviews)
Certified by Cogman's Creek • Mar 01, 2026
Business Details
1376 NJ-23, Butler, NJ
07405, United States
Certified by Cogman's Creek • Mar 01, 2026
(973) 577-4220
Certified by Cogman's Creek • Mar 01, 2026
https://cogmans.com
Certified by Cogman's Creek • Mar 01, 2026
About
Certified by Cogman's Creek • Mar 01, 2026
Butcher Shop
Details
- DeliveryAvailable
- Curbside pickupAvailable
Location
Certified by Cogman's Creek • Mar 01, 2026
Hours
Certified by Cogman's Creek • Mar 01, 2026
Reviews
4.6
208 reviews
5 stars
173
4 stars
13
3 stars3
2 stars2
1 star
17
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Food Quality
Customers consistently praised the quality and taste of the food, particularly the steaks and sandwiches.
Customer Service
Feedback was mixed; while many appreciated the friendly staff, several reviews highlighted instances of rudeness and poor handling of customer complaints.
Pricing
Many customers noted that while the food is excellent, prices are on the higher side, leading to some complaints about value.
Order Accuracy
There were multiple reports of incorrect orders and issues with online ordering, causing frustration among customers.
- RVRob VanDeusen4 days ago5.0Best food around
- SPStephen PFeb 20, 20265.0This place always hits been coming for year or two never disappoints
- RRrodroFeb 14, 20261.0Rude. Disrespectful owner.
- VZVasili ZiangosFeb 9, 20265.0If you are looking for a Steak Sandwich like the good ole days this is the place to get it. Pulled Pork sweet potato fries also fantastic. Heard great things about the wings, I haven't tried them yet but they are on the list.
- RLRachel LeeFeb 4, 20261.0We’ve been loyal customers of Cogman’s Creek for years — lunches, catering, and regular orders — but this experience was so disappointing and honestly upsetting. I have severe allergies, and onions are one of my highest-risk triggers that can cause severe allergic reactions. I ordered the Cheese Steak Wrap and left a very clear note requesting NO onions. When I got home, my order was wrong. I called the restaurant and instead of an apology, I was met with a condescending response: “Well what do you want us to do? Want a new one?” When I politely said yes please and thank you, the call was abruptly ended. A few minutes later, a man named Steve called and immediately began questioning me about toppings, then berated me, insisting I “should know” the wrap comes with peppers and mushrooms — even though the menu description only lists: “Sliced steak, cheddar cheese, sautéed onions.” There is no mention anywhere of peppers or mushrooms. I double-checked the menu while on the phone and confirmed that. When I returned to pick up the remake, I was made to wait in line again awkwardly while Steve chatted casually, even after I asked to speak with the person who called me. When I explained what happened and showed screenshots, I was brushed off with “sorry sweetie.” I run a food blog with over 20K followers, and I genuinely love supporting local small businesses and helping them grow — which makes this even more upsetting. Mistakes happen, but ignoring an allergy note, blaming the customer for menu inaccuracies, and being rude and dismissive is unacceptable. I left nearly in tears. If you have allergies or dietary restrictions, please be extremely cautious ordering here.
Frequently Asked Questions About Cogman's Creek
What are the general operating hours of Cogman's Creek?
Cogman's Creek is open daily from 10:00 AM to 7:00 PM Monday through Saturday, and from 10:00 AM to 4:00 PM on Sundays.
Does Cogman's Creek offer delivery and pickup services?
Yes, Cogman's Creek provides both in-store pickup and delivery options for customers.
When can I order takeout from Cogman's Creek?
Takeout is available from 10:00 AM to 6:40 PM Monday through Saturday, and from 10:00 AM to 3:40 PM on Sundays.
What types of cuisine does Cogman's Creek serve?
Cogman's Creek offers a variety of foods including butcher shop meats, deli items, Italian and American dishes, pasta, hamburgers, sandwiches, vegetarian options, and catering services.
Where is Cogman's Creek located?
Cogman's Creek is located at 1376 NJ-23, Butler, NJ 07405, United States.
How can I view the menu or place an order online?
You can view the menu and place orders online by visiting https://cogmans.com/menu.
What is the phone number to contact Cogman's Creek?
The main phone number for Cogman's Creek is +1 973-577-4220.
Are there any wellness or spa services near Cogman's Creek?
Yes, nearby wellness and spa options include '23 Spa | Asian Massage Butler NJ' and 'Dream Spa 23'. Visitors can enjoy relaxation services before or after dining.
What nearby places can I visit for beauty and salon services near Cogman's Creek?
Nearby beauty services include 'Kay Nails', 'True Colors Nail & Spa', and 'Precision Plus Haircutters' offering nail, spa, and hair salon options.
Are there any nearby food or grocery stores to visit alongside Cogman's Creek?
Yes, 'Green Life Market' is a nearby health food and grocery store, and there's also a 'Dunkin'' coffee shop for additional food and beverage options.
Brand Certified Facts from Cogman's Creek
Cogman's Creek partners directly with Yext to publish this data from the brand's official system of record. Learn more about our data sources
Certified March 01, 2026Yext Knowledge Graph
- Address
- Categories
- Geo coordinates
- Legal business name
- Hours of operation
- Phone number
- Official website