Overall, customers praised the pizza and cheesesteaks, with many calling them the best in Bayonne and highlighting unique flavors and generous portions.
Service Issues
Several reviews mentioned poor customer service experiences, including rude staff interactions and long wait times for orders.
Cleanliness
While many customers appreciated the cleanliness of the establishment, some noted issues with dirty tables and restrooms.
Pricing Concerns
Customers expressed mixed feelings about pricing, with some finding the food overpriced compared to quality, while others felt it was worth the cost.
Delivery Experience
There were complaints about delivery delays and issues with the ordering process, particularly regarding communication and order accuracy.
FJ
frank marto jr
Nov 14, 2025
5.0
The cheese steak is one of the Best ,my wife and I picked up one Monday it was so good.after the Flyers game on Saturday we stopped at Angelo's in Philly your steak is exactly the same only difference Angelo's bread is more crispy a I think the reason is Angelo's makes there bread in house
RM
Renato Miranda
Nov 14, 2025
3.0
I had big expectations when I visited this place because some people claim this to be the best cheesesteak in Bayonne but my cheesesteak ended up being just average for me. The meat was tasty but it was lacking cheese and onions so it was dry. If you compare my photos to the other ones the others look much juicier and cheesier.
Placing an order online was easy, they have the link on their instagram page. Order was ready on time and the pick up process was also easy.
I paid around $17 with taxes but for this price I expected more.
NK
Nicholas Kovacs
Nov 8, 2025
5.0
Ive had a hard time finding good pizza in this area BUT THIS PLACE IS LEGIT!!! The staff are on top of their game, when they are busy they are moving and still friendly and take care of yah.
So far while staying in the area Ive had the Cheesesteak Sicilian, and the Vodka Brooklyn add meatballs and sausage. Both were phenomenal. Parking is tough sometimes but it’s worth it and they are fast if you order online.
EDIT: tried the cheesesteak…. Absolute heaven
RP
Rachel Pisani
Nov 2, 2025
5.0
By far the best chicken parm and cheesesteak sandwich I’ve ever had. The customer service is excellent and I try a new pizza every time I place a new order. Each pie better than the last. This place has EXCELLENT FOOD and is always busy so definitely order ahead if you order take out. The food and staff blew me away!!! 10/10 !!
AA
Alex
Oct 23, 2025
1.0
Disappointing. We had a plan pie and a special Sicilian. The sicilian was 6/10 the plan was very low mid for Bayonne 3.5/10. Plain pie had a weird smell and taste. We all had diarrhea the next day. Also the sicilian pies are rather expensive for the size and quality. Sicilian is 2/3 the size of what im use to only 6 slices. Very light on the toppings. $50 for the 2 pies and delivery.
Called to order was told to use online menu for uber eats to deliver at that point I should have know. Uber eats doesn't use a pizza bag the the pizza gets to us relatively cold.
This is not my first time having this place but it will be my last.
I hope the quality droped off since Dave from barstool was here really makes me wonder about his other reviews.
What are the regular opening hours of Corner Square?
Corner Square is open from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM Tuesday through Thursday, 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM on Friday and Saturday, and 12:00 PM to 9:00 PM on Sunday. It is closed on Mondays.
Is Corner Square open on public holidays?
Corner Square is closed on December 25, 2025, and may close on other holidays as well.
What services does Corner Square offer for food pickup and delivery?
Corner Square offers in-store pickup, delivery, and curbside pickup services for your convenience.
What are the delivery hours for Corner Square?
Delivery is available from 11:00 AM to 8:30 PM Tuesday through Thursday, 11:00 AM to 9:30 PM on Friday and Saturday, and 12:00 PM to 8:30 PM on Sunday. Delivery is not available on Mondays.
Can I place a takeout order at Corner Square?
Yes, Corner Square offers takeout services during their regular hours, excluding Mondays when they are closed.
Where is Corner Square located?
Corner Square is located at 956 Broadway, Bayonne, NJ 07002, United States.
How can I view the menu and place an order online for Corner Square?
You can view the menu and place your order online at https://cornersquarepizzeria.com/menu.
Are there any nearby restaurants where I can explore after dining at Corner Square?
Yes, nearby restaurants include Americano, Mediterraneo, and Angelina's, offering a variety of dining experiences you may want to explore.
What nearby amenities can help me while visiting Corner Square?
You can find convenient amenities nearby such as T&J Hand Car Wash, Garden State Community Bank, and Broadway Health Pharmacy for your vehicle, banking, and health needs.
Are there any nearby cultural or historical sites to visit near Corner Square?
Yes, nearby you can visit the Bayonne Truck House No. 1, a historical building and museum, as well as the Chief John T Brennan Fire Museum for an enriching experience.