Corner Square

Reviews

• TT

  TOXICHAMMERTOE

  5 days ago
  2.0
  I'm giving this place a 2 star and there's a reason. THEY LITERALLY TRIED TO SELL ME A BURNT PIZZA! The young girl nice girl left my pizza slices 2 pepperoni in the oven Too long to be warmed up. It's an honest mistake. Problem that I have is that I guess it was the owner's son who's about 18 or 17 years old try to literally sell me that trash. I had to call him out and says I don't want burnt pizza so I noticed he took one slice away and I didn't unmistakably check the other 1. The other slice was burnt like almost like charcoal on the bottom. If you're gonna order from them, do not get your pizza warmed up because they're gonna burn your PIZZA and Instead of doing what's right and taken the loss, they're gonna try to sell it to you for $5 dollars a slice which I do NOT appreciate. ... The replacement slice that I asked to have the girl asked me (nicely) if i would warm it up I said "NO thank you, I learned my lesson.".. The Pizza does taste good though but because of that bad service I just can't trust A place a business like that because the other employees the 'older men' were watching the situation didn't say "NOTTEN"... It's supposed to be Corner Square Pizza not Coal Miner's CHARCOAL BURNT PIZZA!
• JX

  Joe F. (Sku11R34P3R X13)

  6 days ago
  5.0
  Cheesesteaks are epic, chicken cheesesteaks are just as great, and the buffalo soldier pie is on point! Previously tried the Sicilian hot honey pepperoni pie and it was delicious as well. Good food, can't complain about a Corner Square slice or Cheesesteak sandwich!
• TM

  Toby Mason

  Feb 21, 2026
  1.0
  I ordered 3 cheesesteaks and a plain cheese pie. Cheesesteaks are always good no complaints. This was my first time ordering a plain pie and it was not good by any means. All my children said it smelt like cleaning products and tasted off. I called the store to inform the manager and his response was "Thank you" and hung up the phone. No apology, no possible explanation, nothing. Very disappointed and left me surprised considering we've ordered here often with no complaints. Even with their specialty slices have always been great. Unfortunately this will be my last visit due to the lack of customer service or lack of concern. FYI I was only calling to inform you of our concern, wasn't looking for reimbursement or a remake just to make you aware. Wasn't sure if it was because the store just opened or what but I hope you treat other "complaints" more seriously.
• JR

  Joanne Ragazzo

  Feb 19, 2026
  5.0
  I did a home delivery for this purchase. Delivery was a little later than I requested but the food was delicious. Two different salads... both very good portions and both really good. Cheesesteak was huge...I was able to get 2 meals out of it and it was tasty and cheesy! Italian donut was delish... kind of like a zeppoli stuffed with cannoli cream. I'll be re-ordering soon!
• EW

  Ebony Williams

  Feb 11, 2026
  4.0
  I tried this place a few weeks ago through Grubhub and have been pretty happy with their dishes overall. I would recommend that they focus on consistency with both portions and flavor. The cheesesteak is delicious, and the chicken vodka parmesan is my favorite and I’ve ordered it about four times. Unfortunately, my last sandwich was disappointing. It felt sloppy, and the cutlet was so small and thin that it didn’t seem worth the price. The wings are why I deducted one star. I’ve tried both the Honey BBQ and Teriyaki flavors, but the chicken was so heavily salted that it overpowered the sauces and made them inedible. If this place can remain consistent with their flavors and portions, it will be an absolute gem in the Bayonne neighborhood.