Many customers praised the unique and delicious flavors of the food, particularly the vegan options and specialty pizzas.
Service Issues
Several reviews highlighted poor customer service experiences, including long wait times and unresponsive staff.
Cleanliness
Multiple customers noted that the establishment was not clean, with sticky tables and a generally unkempt appearance.
Value for Money
Some customers felt that the prices were too high for the quality of food received, while others believed it was worth the cost.
LB
LENINYER BUENO
Jan 5, 2026
4.0
I'd been meaning to go to Boloney Rex for a while when I traveled to Atlantic City. I finally went and loved it. The portion is good for two people.
CK
Cody KOhler
Jan 1, 2026
2.0
This was my go to pizza place in Atlantic City. The last time I went I ordered a pizza online. When I got there it wasn't ready, but I was early so I didn't mind. I was told it was just going in the oven, so it would take a little while. I waited a long time and checked back.They said it would be ready soon. The person actually lied to me to try to cover her mistake. A few minutes later I saw them putting a pizza in the oven that looked like mine. I asked and it was mine.
I was sent a survey about the order that I filled out and let them know about this situation. I couldn't believe they never got back to me.
SC
Scrappy Cat
Dec 31, 2025
5.0
Outstanding! The best vegan & vegetarian sandwiches we have ever had. Seitan is top-notch. Eggplant meatballs are phenomenal. Everything was just perfect!
JG
Jackie Gaskill
Dec 21, 2025
5.0
Live near Cape May but have been dying to try the food based on posts on FB. Were finally in the area so decided to try it today. Were not disappointed! AMAZING food. Will be making more trips for this delicious food!
BA
BX A
Dec 11, 2025
5.0
The Vegan Pinky is the most flavorful and deliciously spicy pepperoni pizza I’ve ever had!!! Do yourself a favor and get a 12” pie made fresh and save a few slices in the fridge for the next day! Yum!! This place (along with 7 Sisters just outside AC) is a godsend for Vegans visiting the vegan desert that is Atlantic City.
Update: Went back for the Vegan Cheesesteak Ole… a super messy and satisfying sandwich that is huge and enough for two people. Great vegan steak sandwich! The fries are solid and hearty!
Frequently Asked Questions About Tony Boloney's - Atlantic City
What are the regular business hours of Tony Boloney's Atlantic City?
Tony Boloney's Atlantic City is open from 11:00 AM to 8:00 PM Monday through Thursday and Sunday, and from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM on Friday and Saturday.
Does Tony Boloney's offer delivery and takeout options?
Yes, Tony Boloney's offers both delivery and in-store pickup services for takeout orders.
What types of cuisine and food options does Tony Boloney's provide?
Tony Boloney's serves pizza, Italian dishes, sandwiches, chicken wings, and vegan options, operating as a fast-food and family restaurant.
Where is Tony Boloney's located?
Tony Boloney's is located at 300 Oriental Ave, Atlantic City, NJ 08401, USA.
How can I view the menu or place an order online for Tony Boloney's?
You can view the menu and place orders online at https://tonyboloneys.com/menu.
What is the price range at Tony Boloney's Atlantic City?
Tony Boloney's Atlantic City has a price range categorized as 'TWO', indicating moderately priced offerings.
Are there any nearby entertainment venues accessible when visiting Tony Boloney's?
Yes, Ovation Hall, a concert and music venue, is nearby for arts and entertainment before or after your meal.
What beaches are close to Tony Boloney's where customers can visit?
Customers can visit nearby beaches such as Crystal Beach, New Hampshire Avenue Beach, and Seaside Ave. Atlantic City Beach for leisure.
Are there any notable landmarks near Tony Boloney's worth visiting?
Yes, the Absecon Lighthouse, a historic landmark and museum, is near Tony Boloney's and makes for a great visit.
What nearby places can help customers find Tony Boloney's or provide additional amenities?
Nearby places such as Vermont Plaza Apartments and Metropolitan Plaza serve as landmarks, while Alpha and Omega Market offers grocery and convenience store amenities close to Tony Boloney's.