Many customers praised the food for its unique flavors and quality ingredients, particularly the pizzas and sandwiches.
Service Issues
Several reviews highlighted poor service experiences, including long wait times and issues with order accuracy.
Cleanliness
Multiple customers reported unsanitary conditions in the restaurant, including dirty tables and a generally unkempt environment.
Pricing Concerns
Some customers felt that the prices were too high for the quality of food received, leading to disappointment.
Customer Experience
While many enjoyed the food and atmosphere, there were notable complaints about the overall customer experience, including staff interactions.
KT
Kunal Teeda
Nov 17, 2025
1.0
For all the hype of being a crowd favorite in Atlantic City. It was a pretty bad experience for me. The guy behind the register was high out of his mind and that wasn’t even the bad part of the experience.
The pizzas were a travesty. They should quit experimenting and doing pizzas that cater to a certain crowd. Stick to traditional pizzas minus the experimentation because the pizzas don’t taste as good as they sound.
CS
Cynthia von Schlichten
Nov 4, 2025
5.0
Love the vegan offerings at Tony’s….amazing!!
AR
Arlene Rowley
Oct 26, 2025
5.0
Food was great, as usual. Love the option of fries instead of a roll. However, when a sandwich is on a roll, and topped with cheese, sometimes (with takeout) the paper sticks to the top of the sandwich and I lose some of its deliciousness.
RB
Raquel Braemer
Oct 25, 2025
5.0
Recently moved to the area and found our new favorite delivery place. We're working our way through trying all of the pizzas. We haven't had one we didn't like! Love that we can get a "half and half" with 2 different pizza toppings on one pizza.
JJ
J
Oct 21, 2025
5.0
U can literally buy a slice a pizza with whatever on it 🥵love this place they also sell food after hours for cheap they have an app where u can pay and pick the order up
Frequently Asked Questions About Tony Boloney's - Atlantic City
What are the regular business hours of Tony Boloney's Atlantic City?
Tony Boloney's Atlantic City is open from 11:00 AM to 8:00 PM Monday through Thursday and Sunday, and from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM on Friday and Saturday.
Does Tony Boloney's offer delivery and takeout options?
Yes, Tony Boloney's offers both delivery and in-store pickup services for takeout orders.
What types of cuisine and food options does Tony Boloney's provide?
Tony Boloney's serves pizza, Italian dishes, sandwiches, chicken wings, and vegan options, operating as a fast-food and family restaurant.
Where is Tony Boloney's located?
Tony Boloney's is located at 300 Oriental Ave, Atlantic City, NJ 08401, USA.
How can I view the menu or place an order online for Tony Boloney's?
You can view the menu and place orders online at https://tonyboloneys.com/menu.
What is the price range at Tony Boloney's Atlantic City?
Tony Boloney's Atlantic City has a price range categorized as 'TWO', indicating moderately priced offerings.
Are there any nearby entertainment venues accessible when visiting Tony Boloney's?
Yes, Ovation Hall, a concert and music venue, is nearby for arts and entertainment before or after your meal.
What beaches are close to Tony Boloney's where customers can visit?
Customers can visit nearby beaches such as Crystal Beach, New Hampshire Avenue Beach, and Seaside Ave. Atlantic City Beach for leisure.
Are there any notable landmarks near Tony Boloney's worth visiting?
Yes, the Absecon Lighthouse, a historic landmark and museum, is near Tony Boloney's and makes for a great visit.
What nearby places can help customers find Tony Boloney's or provide additional amenities?
Nearby places such as Vermont Plaza Apartments and Metropolitan Plaza serve as landmarks, while Alpha and Omega Market offers grocery and convenience store amenities close to Tony Boloney's.