Margaritaville - Atlantic City

Reviews

• KB

  Kimberly Boone

  1 day ago
  1.0
  We ate here last night. Definitely was not worth the time ⏰️ or 💰. The water 💧 tasted God awful 😖 The food took about a hour and a half to come out. The whole vibe was off. Definitely will not be eating here again!! And the waitress acted as if we was getting everything free or like we was bothering her or so to speak. Definitely don't recommend.
• NC

  Nico Caltagirone

  2 days ago
  5.0
  Food wasn’t the best. It came out cold and lacking of flavor. But the service was great. Our server cam was on point and very very sweet and met all our needs. The manager also was understanding when we complained about the satisfaction of the food. She accommodated things and was very sympathetic.
• DS

  Dennis Swope

  2 days ago
  1.0
  We waited for 40 minutes for our food before the manager came and apologized for the delay and said it would be 5 to 7 more minutes. After another 15 minutes and seeing all the other tables getting their food it was time to go. I have never walked away from a restaurant before. Usually very patient and understanding but very disappointed in the service. I RECOMMEND finding somewhere else to eat.
• TM

  Troy Milbourne

  4 days ago
  5.0
  Ashley & Andrew truly made our dining experience unforgettable! From the moment we walked in, their energy was warm, welcoming, and so attentive. Ashley was so sweet and made sure we had everything we needed without even having to ask. Andrew was just as amazing — knowledgeable about the menu and gave the best recommendations! The service was quick, professional, and full of personality. You can tell they genuinely care about their guests and take pride in what they do. Because of them, the whole experience felt personal and enjoyable. If you get seated with Ashley & Andrew, just know you’re in good hands. We’ll definitely be back! Ashley & Andrew truly made our dining experience unforgettable! From the moment we walked in, their energy was warm, welcoming, and so attentive. Ashley was so sweet and made sure we had everything we needed without even having to ask. Andrew was just as amazing — knowledgeable about the menu and gave the best recommendations! The service was quick, professional, and full of personality. You can tell they genuinely care about their guests and take pride in what they do. Because of them, the whole experience felt personal and enjoyable. If you get seated with Ashley & Andrew, just know you’re in good hands. We’ll definitely be back!
• CC

  Cero0tr3s

  Feb 17, 2026
  4.0
  I want to be very clear: the 3-star rating is strictly for the management's failure to staff this location properly. The food was actually good. We enjoyed the ribs, pasta, and chicken tenders. However, the highlight of our visit was Ashley. She was doing the work of three people: acting as the manager, seating guests, cleaning tables, and serving, all while maintaining a professional attitude. She did an incredible job despite being put in an impossible situation by the company. It is unfair to employees like Ashley to be left so short-staffed. She is the only reason this isn't a 1-star review for the long wait times. Management needs to hire more people to support their excellent staff.

Frequently Asked Questions About Margaritaville - Atlantic City