Jimmy John's

Reviews

• BD

  Beverly Dodge

  Jan 3, 2026
  1.0
  Absolutely the worst experience. We ordered 5 sandwiches online & sent my grandson to pick them up. He waited over an hour. Other customers came & went. The 2 employees working offered no explanation to him for the delay in getting sandwiches except that they had a problem with baking of the wheat bread. Finally my son-in-law went to JJ’s to see what had happened. Grandson still waiting & no sandwiches had been made. Son-in-law said to use another bread other than wheat. Two more customers came & went & still we had no sandwiches. Son-in-law told JJ employee to cancel our order, credit back our payment & he walked out !! Very unprofessional ! Will not return. Subway is fast, friendly & cares for their customers.
• SN

  Sindy Nowlin

  Sep 27, 2025
  5.0
  Their breakfast plates are hearty and filling.
• RJ

  Robin Johnson

  Sep 6, 2025
  5.0
  Thank you, Jimmy John’s in McCook!! We had a large order for the softball team and it was on time, correct, and packaged well!!! You guys are amazing!!! Thank you!!!
• TF

  Theresa Fisher

  Aug 16, 2025
  4.0
  This place is hard to find, but Google maps was spot on. The food was good but the bread tasted old. The place and bathrooms are clean. The service was a little slow, but friendly.
• TL

  Tysen Lempke

  Aug 11, 2025
  1.0
  I’ve been to Mccook’s Jimmy John twice in two days now and each time they put only 1 slice of turkey on each sandwich and that was it. I then went to Holdrege’s Jimmy Johns and they had it perfect, do better McCook.