Business Details
About
Restaurant
America's Hometown Pizza Place™ since 1958. Home of the Original Thin and Original Pizza Buffet. Pizzas are hand-made daily with fresh dough. Choose from a variety of pizzas, pasta, salad, and desserts!
Location
Hours
Reviews
3.9
432 reviews
5 stars
207
4 stars
89
3 stars
59
2 stars
25
1 star
52
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Food Quality
Mixed reviews on food quality; some customers enjoyed fresh pizza while others reported old or cold items on the buffet.
Service
Service quality varied; many praised attentive staff, while others experienced long waits and order mix-ups.
Cleanliness
Concerns about cleanliness, particularly with the salad bar and dining area, were noted by several customers.
Value
Customers appreciated the affordability of the buffet, but some felt the quality did not match the price.
Management
Feedback indicated issues with management responsiveness and staff training, impacting overall customer experience.
- MGmitch garrisOct 26, 20251.0The food on the pizza bar was very low . Our waitress very disappointed never ask if we wanted any thing that was not on the bar. Was the for a hour and when we was getting ready to leave they start bringing out fresh pizza. Now the one employee I would give a 5 Star was the young lady taken care of of the salad bar. She on was point keeping it fresh and clean
- KKKOct 13, 20255.0Me and my sisters love coming here, it’s our fave pizza spot. The buffet is the best deal. The pizza is always fresh and delicious!!
- RWRolanda WilliamsSep 29, 20255.0Great service!! Quick easy seating, and very attentive staff. Great selection of pizzas, salad, and desserts. Reasonable price for buffet.
- BKBurt KanoffSep 28, 20251.0Ordered An XLNY style pizza and it was the worst ! For over $20 it wasn’t worth the cheapest frozen pizza Walmart sells ! Waited in the pick up area about 15 minutes and got completely ignored by the girl that came back there to do something on the register .
- JHJohnny HarrisSep 1, 20255.0Saw their $8 all day ad today (to be clear…. TODAY) and headed straight to Tarboro for the deal. Was told when we got there that deal ended a few days ago and that the price was $11 or $12. We decided to be sat anyway. Service was very polite. Food was atrocious. Tasted old, low quality. We both felt ill afterwards. When we got the bill, they gave us the senior discount which came to $9.99. This was very kind and attempt to make it right. Service level staff were excellent. I would have given this place a much lower overall score, but I was scared owners would do the right thing and offer us another free or deeply discounted buffet and we just wouldn’t hear of it.
Frequently Asked Questions About Pizza Inn
What type of food does Pizza Inn offer?
Pizza Inn offers a variety of hand-made pizzas with fresh dough daily, including Original Thin and Original Pizza Buffet, as well as pasta, salad, and desserts.
What are the operating hours of Pizza Inn in Tarboro?
Pizza Inn is open Monday through Thursday and Sunday from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM, and on Friday and Saturday from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM.
Where is Pizza Inn located in Tarboro?
Pizza Inn is located at 2211 Saint Andrew Street, Tarboro, NC 27886, USA.
How can I place an order online at Pizza Inn?
You can order online at Pizza Inn by visiting https://order.pizzainn.com.
What is Pizza Inn's contact phone number?
You can reach Pizza Inn by phone at +1 252-823-1018.
Does Pizza Inn offer any buffet options?
Yes, Pizza Inn offers the Original Pizza Buffet as part of their menu.
Which nearby stores can I visit after dining at Pizza Inn?
After dining at Pizza Inn, you can visit nearby stores such as Citi Trends for clothing, Food Lion for groceries, and Family Dollar for discount goods and arts and crafts.
Are there any beauty salons close to Pizza Inn in Tarboro?
Yes, nearby beauty salons include Rachel Beauty Salon, BJ's Barber Salon, Royal Kutz, Turning Headz Beauty Salon, and Beauty Mark By IKita.
Can I find car-related services near Pizza Inn?
Yes, near Pizza Inn you can find automotive services at Que's Used Auto Sales, Reliable Rides LLC, S & J Auto Sales Inc, and S & J Auto Rental and Sales Co.
What other professional services are available near Pizza Inn?
Nearby professional services include You Will Love It Realty for real estate, Jackson Hewitt Tax Service for financial advising, and Connection Mobile wireless for mobile phone services.