Sandwich RestaurantFast Food RestaurantRestaurantTake Out RestaurantCatererSubway
Your local Spring Lake Subway® Restaurant at 6761 Overhills Road brings bold new flavors and classic favorites to guests every day. Enjoy our famous Footlongs, 6" sandwiches, wraps, and salads, ordered quickly in the app or online, through convenient delivery, in-restaurant dining, or curbside pickup. We’re proud to offer a fresh alternative to typical fast food with fresh-cut veggies, tasty proteins, fresh-baked bread, and delicious cookies. We’re also here for your catering needs. All Subway® Restaurants are independently owned and operated by business owners who employ talented Sandwich Artists™.
Many customers reported rude and unprofessional behavior from staff, particularly from a shift manager named Gabriella, while others praised individual employees like Samuel and Bryan for their kindness and professionalism.
Stock Issues
Frequent complaints about the store being out of various menu items, including bread and meats, leading to customer dissatisfaction.
Order Accuracy
Numerous reviews highlighted issues with incorrect orders, both for in-store and online purchases, causing frustration among customers.
Cleanliness
Several customers noted unsanitary conditions in the store, including flies and dirty restrooms, which contributed to a negative dining experience.
Staffing Problems
Many reviews mentioned that the store is often understaffed, leading to slow service and overwhelmed employees.
SB
Summer Bell
Jan 2, 2026
1.0
I want to start this by saying I've been here three times in the last year and every time it was unfriendly and weird atmosphere. But this time I decided to actually review because not only was it weird and unfriendly but also I free ripped off. First of all every time I go here there are no other customers. So I write this review understanding that the gentleman working had more than enough time before we walked in to fill the lineup. My husband and I went in trying to get four subs. When I walked up to the bar almost everything was empty. And I'm not exaggerating. I was told that there was only one kind of sliced cheese ( hot pepper)and shredded cheese that would be available. So for each of my sandwiches the gentleman had to walk to the back four separate times to get four different kinds of meat. Starting with the tuna sandwich I got a footlong and the man scraped every bit of tuna he can get out of there which was not a lot and then tried to literally spread it across. When it when it even go to the end of the bread I called him out on this saying that is not very much tuna don't you have to go get more and he said all he had to give for a footlong is three scoops. Three very small scoops. When I insisted he go get more and told him I guess I would have to pay for extra he reluctantly went and got more and charged me for it. Then I went to a ham sandwich which he ran out of him had to go to the back again. Then I had two bmts for which she had to go in the back two more times to get salami and pepperoni. All of the vegetables looked like they were turned down to cold and it was literally freezing the vegetables. I was told they were out of bell peppers. And the only reason we got the fourth sub was because it was posted on the window by three get one free. And of course that is only with an app which my husband didn't know and didn't want to be bothered with so we paid $45 for four subs. My husband did not get a receipt which I am scared to look at how we spent that much money on four subs when one of the sub was literally just ham and lettuce. When I asked my husband what he wanted for dinner initially and we decided on subway we were going to stop at a different location just because my husband and I have been here two other times and it was not great experiences but we decided to reluctantly try it again and they will not be a fourth. This place really needs a hard look at the staff and atmosphere or at least have all the things there to make the sandwich.
MC
Michael Charland
Nov 24, 2025
1.0
It seems like every time I come to this subway it seems like they are never prepared tonight I came by at 7:00pm they had almost no bread available and no more cooking. I tried to order steak and cheese but it was all frozen. All the chairs are up ready to close even though they close at 10:00pm. The two workers are joking around not caring about making orders. There’s even a door dash in there waiting for more than 20 minutes. I wish this was a one time thing but seems like it’s every time I try to get subway.
CF
Christine Fuentes
Nov 20, 2025
1.0
As soon as I walked in, there was no greeting, nothing. I’m Hispanic, and it felt like I wasn’t even acknowledged, despite the fact that I was right there. The employee, Gabriella, seemed more interested in giving Samuel attitude about focusing on online orders, even though I was standing in front of her ready to be served.
What made matters worse was how she suddenly brightened up when a Caucasian customer walked in. She immediately greeted him with enthusiasm, asking how he was doing, and even made sure to give him a 10% military discount which, by the way, I’m also military!
Gabriella’s behavior was completely unprofessional and rude. Samuel, on the other hand, was polite and handled the situation well, even though I’m sure he was frustrated. Honestly, it’s hard to believe this is the type of employee Subway is choosing to lead their store. If Gabriella is in charge of anything, she needs some serious training on customer service and respect for all customers, regardless of their race.
Thank you to Samuel for making my sandwich, but Gabriella, you really need to reconsider your career in customer service. If this is the standard Subway is setting for their staff, they need to rethink who they’re hiring. It was a disappointing experience, to say the least.
LA
Luz Amores
Nov 20, 2025
1.0
I walked into this Subway and was immediately met with attitude from the shift manager, Gabriela. As soon as I arrived, she said—in a very unpleasant, smart-mouthed way—that online orders would be handled first. It wasn’t what she said, but how she said it.
Thankfully, the young employee with dreads, Samuel, stepped in and took care of me. He apologized for her rudeness and said he would make my sandwich himself. While he was helping me, Gabriela repeated that she had told him to focus on online orders first, again in the same rude tone.
Huge thank-you to Samuel for his professionalism and kindness. He handled the situation with respect and made sure I was taken care of. Subway really needs to reevaluate who’s being put in charge of these shifts—customer service is everything. Honestly, Samuel showed better leadership and customer service skills than the actual shift manager.
HB
Heather Broach
Nov 14, 2025
1.0
Ordered two subs through DoorDash. BOTH were completely wrong and sloppy. Very disappointing. Both were missing items and both had extra items that were not ordered. Worse sub I have had EVER. Will not order from there again
What are the operating hours of Subway at Anderson Creek Plaza?
Subway at 6761 Overhills Road, Anderson Creek Plaza, is open every day from 9:00 AM to 10:00 PM.
Does this Subway location offer delivery and pickup options?
Yes, this Subway offers in-store pickup, curbside pickup, and delivery services for your convenience.
Can I dine inside the Subway restaurant at Anderson Creek Plaza?
Yes, this Subway provides dine-in service along with drive-through and other options.
What meal times does Subway at 6761 Overhills Road serve?
This Subway serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner to satisfy your hunger throughout the day.
Where can I view the menu for this Subway location online?
You can view the menu online at https://subway.com/en-us/restaurant/47811-0/menu/?utm_source=yext-other&utm_medium=local&utm_term=acq&utm_content=47811&utm_campaign=evergreen-2020.
Does Subway at Anderson Creek Plaza provide catering services?
Yes, Subway at this location offers catering services for your events and gatherings.
What is the address and contact number for Subway in Spring Lake, NC?
The Subway at Anderson Creek Plaza is located at 6761 Overhills Road, Shop 110, Spring Lake, NC 28390. The phone number is +1 910-495-9241.
What other businesses are near Subway at Anderson Creek Plaza that I might visit?
Nearby places include Vape + (a tobacco shop), Damon Brazidabarber Henry (a barber and beauty salon), and Qwik Pack & Ship Anderson Creek (shipping and printing services).
Are there dining options near Subway for alternative cuisines?
Yes, nearby dining options include El Burrito Mexican Restaurant for Tex-Mex, China Star for Chinese cuisine, and Domino’s for pizza.
What nearby services might be convenient to visit before or after eating at Subway?
You can visit Family Dollar for shopping or Fit4Life Health Clubs for fitness, both close to Subway at Anderson Creek Plaza.