Business Details
About
Restaurant
America's Hometown Pizza Place™ since 1958. Home of the Original Thin and Original Pizza Buffet. Pizzas are hand-made daily with fresh dough. Choose from a variety of pizzas, pasta, salad, and desserts!
Location
Hours
Reviews
4.2
1,249 reviews
5 stars
746
4 stars
250
3 stars
121
2 stars
53
1 star
79
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Food Quality
Customers praised the pizza for being hot, fresh, and delicious, with a variety of options available, though some noted inconsistencies in quality during different times of day.
Service
The staff received high marks for friendliness and attentiveness, with several standout servers like Mary and Jackie being frequently mentioned for their excellent service.
Cleanliness
While many reviews noted the restaurant was clean, some customers pointed out issues with the buffet area needing more frequent cleaning and restocking.
Pricing
Several customers felt that the prices were high for the quality and quantity of food offered, leading to mixed feelings about value.
Atmosphere
The restaurant was described as family-friendly with a warm and welcoming atmosphere, although some reviews mentioned issues with service during busy times.
- ASAurora StanleyNov 5, 20255.0Delicious food, excellent service.
- DCD & D Pest Control Co.Oct 31, 20255.0Stopped by the Pizza Inn in Selma, NC, and wow—what a treat! Their pizza buffet was absolutely excellent! Every slice was hot, fresh, and perfectly cheesy. The variety was on point—from classic pepperoni to those delicious dessert pizzas that make you go back for “just one more.” 🍕 The staff was friendly, the restaurant was spotless, and the atmosphere was warm and welcoming—exactly what you want when you’re hungry and craving comfort food. You can tell they take pride in their service and their pizza game. 🍕 Appreciation: Big thanks to the crew at Pizza Inn in Selma for keeping the buffet full and flavorful. Y’all are doing it right—definitely a 5-star stop when traveling through Eastern North Carolina!
- JLJames LundyOct 27, 20252.0It’s old and rundown but the price is what kills me! 4 ppl after tax and tip is almost $80. That is insanely overpriced for what this is! I will never go back!
- AWAmy WoolseyOct 23, 20255.0Best seat up at a pizza inn that I have ever seen.
- JBJamie BryantOct 1, 20251.0We have given this location chance after chance after chance and there is ALWAYS an issue. From old pizza to no pizza to old lettuce, there's ALWAYS some kind of issue at this location. This was our last trip and we waiting for over 15 minutes for the buffet to be restocked and they brought out maybe 4 pizzas and none were what anyone wanted. My daughter ate and the rest if us didn't. We will not be back and I warn anyone coming here to check the buffet for quantity and quality before you sit down. Staff is very nice though and the restaurant is clean. Just never have food it seems.
Frequently Asked Questions About Pizza Inn
What is Pizza Inn known for?
Pizza Inn is America's Hometown Pizza Place™ since 1958, known for the Original Thin and Original Pizza Buffet with hand-made daily fresh dough pizzas.
What types of food does Pizza Inn offer?
Pizza Inn offers a variety of pizzas, pasta, salads, and desserts.
What are the operating hours of Pizza Inn in Selma, NC?
Pizza Inn is open daily from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM.
Where is Pizza Inn located in Selma?
Pizza Inn is located at 1441 South Pollock Street, Selma, NC 27576, USA.
How can I place an order online for Pizza Inn?
You can place your order online through Pizza Inn's order website at https://order.pizzainn.com.
What is the contact phone number for Pizza Inn in Selma?
The local phone number for Pizza Inn is +1 919-965-4400.
Which nearby automotive services can I visit around Pizza Inn?
Nearby automotive services include Strickland Brothers 10 Minute Oil Change and Advance Auto Parts, which can be convenient for car maintenance before or after your meal.
Are there any nearby shipping or courier locations close to Pizza Inn?
Yes, you can find a UPS Access Point location and The UPS Store nearby for your shipping and courier needs.
What financial services are near Pizza Inn in Selma?
Nearby financial services include Western Union for money transfers, Truist ATM for cash withdrawals, Coinme for currency exchange, and Liberty Tax for tax services.
Are there any nearby stores or markets I can visit along with Pizza Inn?
Food Lion grocery store, Big Lots discount store, and Crooked Row Produce farmers market are nearby options you can visit before or after enjoying your meal at Pizza Inn.