Sugar Creek Seafood Restaurant

Reviews

• SG

  Stacey Gordon

  Feb 8, 2026
  1.0
  Drove 2 hours on a Saturday to eat here because your website said you were open. Got there to an empty parking lot and closed sign. Very bad for business. Won't be back.
• ML

  Multi Purpose Dan LLC

  Jan 4, 2026
  1.0
  2025-1-3 drove an hour and forty five minutes to eat at this establishment. Google maps said it opened at 4pm. Got there and a sign was on the doo saying it was closed for the season. Really? Up dat your Google maps hours so your not sending people on a wild goose chase. Wasn't happy at all. Waste of time and fuel. Whoever is the General Manager of the restaurant should have been on top of that.
• PB

  Penny Bashlor

  Nov 7, 2025
  3.0
  4 friends out for dinner. We were seated in an area that looked like a hallway with windows but at night unable to see out the windows. Our waitress was late greeting us, left without offering drinks and came back 5 to 10 mins later. The cornbread was delivered cold. One of the group ordered the fried fish that was curled up in a ball and poorly cooked. Two said their food was “o.k.”. I don’t even recall what I ordered. Not memorable enough to even comment on the dish. We decided that there were too many great seafood restaurants that we would not choose this one again.
• BR

  brian Ricci

  Oct 30, 2025
  1.0
  Called in to ask about if reservations needed young lady advised no verified time from website. website states it's open until 9pm took entire family in around 730 pm they closed entire restaurant down mentioned time there website states hostess were not accommodating or pleasant at all this was our go to place I don't think I'll ever return now . Restaurant needs to do a better job of updating hours online.
• DH

  Dennis Hosch

  Oct 25, 2025
  5.0
  Loved the very friendly waitress, who said they had the best shrimp on the beach. The shrimp and everything else we had was great, and reasonably priced.