Papa Johns Pizza

Reviews

• SS

  sgand

  Feb 6, 2026
  1.0
  Ordered a specialty pizza and was delivered a cheaper alternative without being told. Instead of calling me for approval or asking what I wanted to do, they just sent the cheaper pizza. Called and spoke with Keith (claimed to be the manager and sounded completely incompetent) who said they don’t carry the ingredients for what I ordered, so they sent the cheaper alternative instead. Refused a refund unless I drove the incorrect pizza back. It's unreasonable to expect me to spend my own time and money to correct their mistake. "Yeah, I don't know what to tell you" is not the correct response, Keith. We won’t be ordering again.
• JB

  Janet Bridges

  Nov 23, 2025
  1.0
  Tonight I ordered two pizzas and an order of bacon cheese sticks from the Morehead City location. When I received my order, the toppings on one of the pizzas had slid off half of the pizza. I immediately called the store and the lady I spoke with said that she would send another one out right away. For some reason I had not even checked the bread sticks. Just like the pizza, the toppings had slid off of half and it was cut like a pizza, in eight triangle pieces. I immediately called back, spoke to the same lady and she said that she was going to remake my Entire order and send it out right away. Approximately 15 minutes later, my order arrived and it was for one pizza. My husband questioned the driver and she called the store. She was told that the rest of the order was assigned to a different driver and would be here shortly. It has now been two hours and there is no sign of the remainder of my order. $50 for two pizzas and an order of bacon cheese sticks is insult enough but to not make good on your word to make it right, is more than I am willing to tolerate. This is not the first time that I’ve had issues with this location but it is definitely the last. Papa John’s has lost my business forever.
• SB

  Sidi bah

  Apr 23, 2024
  5.0
  Their pizza is fabulous! The only problem I have is that they only deliver on the weekends, but it is worth picking up during the week if you want some good pizza. Please be sure to leave a tip for the girls. They do a great job!

Frequently Asked Questions About Papa Johns Pizza