Johnny Brusco's New York Style Pizza

Reviews

• SS

  SnacKing

  Feb 11, 2026
  4.0
  Solid Pizza joint, nice people, pretty good prices on most things but I have one big issue. Topping prices are INSANE here. Wife has to eat gluten free. The crust is $14 for a 10 inch (no big deal, its pretty standardish for gf). The cheapest topping is $2.09 and goes up to $3 or so. I understand a premium on SOME toppings/extras but to get a few jarred olives on a little 10" pizza for over $2 is crazy to me. Its not like it comes extremely loaded. By the time she gets what she wants its a minimum of $20 on her little pizza if she skimps herself to save. I dont get why there arent better deals on this. Some type of 2 or 3 topping deal etc. Certain toppings just aren't worth the price. I wish they wouldn't put blanket prices on things and actually have realistic price for certain things. I understand meats or more expensive things or things that take more prep. Overall, these are the most expensive toppings across the board I have ever seen. Its why we dont go there as much as we want. I like this spot but cant justify it all of the time.
• CB

  Colin Bedson

  Feb 7, 2026
  5.0
  My family loves the food here. I have recommended them to friends with kids.
• MS

  Mack Sutton

  Jan 22, 2026
  5.0
  First time ordering, great experience! Pizza came hot and fresh, fantastic pizza and wings.I’m funny about crust,but this is a very good crust and sauce,I don’t toss it as usual. Keep up the good work! I’ll be returning/ordering again in the near future. My new pizza place! Recommend!
• MC

  Marc Craig

  Jan 16, 2026
  5.0
  Pizza was excellent. The service was fast.
• SM

  Shelly Miller

  Jan 12, 2026
  5.0
  We just moved to Mooresville from Charlotte. We ordered pizza and wings and noted to have pizza well done and wings crispy. I was so thrilled that they saw my request and made them that way! (Usually places dont even pay attention:( Definitely is going to be our go to in the future!!!! It was so good!