At Papa Johns Pizza in Cary, NC, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it's our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Cary pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Cary or stop by 10236 GREEN LEVEL CHURCH ROAD for carryout to order the best pizza in Cary, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
I ordered my pizza and it was told to me that it was done and when I got there even late, they hadn’t even started. This store is always so poorly under staffed. This is not the first time that this has happened on a Sunday this football season. The ownership needs to assess how they run this business. I don’t think I’ll ever come to this one again and I like Papa John’s better than Marcos and Dominos. But I can’t take waiting for 30 minutes over and again.
BK
Bill King
Nov 21, 2025
1.0
My experience is from the perspective of a Door Dash driver. I'm sure the pizza and wings are fine, but the service was deplorable - orders were stacking up and the location was filling up with customers and delivery drivers. Maybe they don't have enough workers and/or equipment to keep up on a busy Thursday night. It was like a circus.
I had two orders to pick up. The first one was nearly ready when I arrived. For the second order, I have no clue. Someone mentioned that the pizza was out, and I heard them call out that the next batch of wings would be for my customer. That was after at least a 20 minute wait. Ten minutes later, still no wings.
So 35+ minutes of waiting with no food - and no communication. One of the workers allowed me access to the warming rack to put my first order back. Later, I stepped back toward the rack just to get a peek, and the manager, Brian, went berserk. Ten or so minutes later, I asked for only the third time about the order; this time he accused me of harassment and asked me to leave the establishment, which I did.
This whole situation could have been prevented, had the manager or any of the employees given any eye contact or acknowledgment that there were people waiting; and to provide an update on any of the orders. But that was not the case. Like I said, it was a circus. The manager, whose sole function appeared to be peeling stickers and applying them to cardboard boxes, could benefit from anger management training and from training in basic social skills.
But good things can come from bad. Going forward, we have joined fellow DoorDashers and UberEats drivers in avoiding Papa John's like the plague. We lost revenue waiting over 30 minutes for nothing.
PostScript: shortly after this incident, I called the store and spoke to the manager for the purpose of getting his name that I might include in this review. Shortly afterwards, he called me back and threatened me with trespassing charges if I ever returned to that location.
Seriously, you can't make this stuff up.
MM
M M
Nov 9, 2025
2.0
Pizza is fine but the service is terrible. The guy serving is not nice or welcoming. Give people a smile- it does not hurt. And do not be rude
HF
HEELS Fan
Oct 31, 2025
1.0
Ordered well done pizza and wings- over an hour later, received order. Neither wings or the pizza was well done. Had pizza delivered, and no seal on either item, how would you trust this…
Called store to report, was told that well done orders were not happening due to being busy. I asked why, and reply was “I just work here”. Customer service stinks and now food is terrible
What are the delivery hours for Papa Johns Pizza in Cary, NC?
Papa Johns Pizza offers delivery every day from 10:00 AM to midnight (00:00).
Can I place a takeout order at Papa Johns Pizza? What are the hours?
Yes, Papa Johns Pizza offers takeout every day from 10:00 AM to 11:40 PM.
How can I order food from Papa Johns Pizza online?
You can order online for delivery or carryout through the Papa Johns website or their app using the provided order links.
Where is Papa Johns Pizza located in Cary, NC?
The restaurant is located at 10236 Green Level Church Road, Suite 103, Cary, NC 27519.
Does Papa Johns Pizza offer gift cards?
Yes, you can purchase Papa Johns gift cards through their official website and app.
What types of food and services does Papa Johns Pizza provide?
Papa Johns offers pizza, breadsticks, wings, and desserts with services including delivery, takeout, order ahead, lunch, and dinner.
Are there any places near Papa Johns Pizza where I can shop for groceries?
Yes, nearby grocery shopping options include ALDI, ALDI USA, and Publix Super Market at Amberly Place, which can be convenient for your grocery needs before or after enjoying pizza.
What are some nearby health and medical facilities around Papa Johns Pizza?
Nearby health services include Ivy Rehab Physical Therapy, Dental Care of Cary Park, Cary Dental Arts, and Walgreens pharmacy, making it convenient for healthcare visits while in the area.
Are there any nearby schools or learning centers near Papa Johns Pizza?
Yes, you will find Gifted Stars Early Learning Academy, Cary Learning Academy, AspireMax Academy (Math Tutor), and Kumon Math and Reading Center close by for educational needs.
How can I contact Papa Johns Pizza in Cary?
You can call them at +1 919-439-2074 for orders or inquiries.