America's Hometown Pizza Place™ since 1958. Home of the Original Thin and Original Pizza Buffet. Pizzas are hand-made daily with fresh dough. Choose from a variety of pizzas, pasta, salad, and desserts!
Many customers found the pizza lacking in flavor and freshness, with reports of cold and stale items on the buffet.
Service Issues
Numerous reviews highlighted rude and unprofessional staff, with complaints about long wait times and incorrect orders.
Cleanliness Concerns
Several customers reported unsanitary conditions, including roaches and dirty dining areas.
Positive Staff Interactions
Despite negative experiences, some customers praised friendly staff and good service during their visits.
Value for Money
While some found the buffet reasonably priced, others felt the overall cost was too high for the quality of food provided.
JT
Jessica Thatcher
Feb 20, 2026
2.0
We ordered a cheese pizza, a supreme and a ham and onion pizza. The cheese pizza was seriously lacking flavor and extremely greasy. The ham and onion had barely any ham and the onions could not even be tasted. The supreme was the best tasting out of the three, but still lacked flavor. I don't think the pizza sauce had any flavoring at all. In all honesty, frozen pizza from the grocery tastes way better and is about $50 cheaper! We won't be ordering from any pizza inn ever again. Very disappointed!
CC
Carl
Feb 15, 2026
5.0
Very nice people! A community asset.
JJ
jenifer jancus
Feb 4, 2026
5.0
Everyone's really nice foods great being from NY saying pizza is good here really means something! 😁
RM
Ronnie Montgomery
Jan 11, 2026
1.0
Jessica has been rude every time I’ve brought my family in. Don’t recommend if you’re looking for good food and friendly service.
LM
Lauren Montgomery
Jan 11, 2026
1.0
Staff and management, specifically Jessica and Robin are very rude and unprofessional. It’s very sad because the options are so limited in a small town, and the owners are good kind people, and it has the potential to be a great place for family.