Papa Johns Pizza

Reviews

• TG

  Todd Greife

  3 days ago
  1.0
  Did carryout from this location. Arrived to a locked door at 11:30 a.m. that took the staff about five minutes to get opened. Then when I got the pizza to my work, the center was close to raw dough and even the end crusts had some uncooked aspects in the center. Which would explain why my pizza was done almost 10 minutes sooner than the app advised.
• TI

  Travis Ince

  Jan 14, 2026
  1.0
  Well the one manager who kept this location moving is now gone. The remaining employees are antisocial and perpetually behind schedule. Business hours are merely a suggestion, not a guarantee. Sarpinos at 40 hwy/Shrank is amazing if you’re looking for a better alternative.
• JB

  Jen Black

  Jan 27, 2022
  1.0
  Came to leave a review and after reading through the others realize everything has already been said but here it goes anyway - We ordered from here January 23, 2022 and spent about $80.00 Firstly - NY style pizza is definitely NOT NY style - so don’t get your hopes up - second our garlic knots were overcooked and almost burnt - I called the store to discuss these issues and return the food for better and more properly made food - Heather answered the phone who is allegedly the store manager - she originally tried to say that the order didn’t come from that store “because they hadn’t made garlic knots all day” then when I informed her that this is the store phone number that was listed in my email telling me to call with any issues - she looked for the order under my name and found it - Then she proceeded to tell me that she personally cooked our order and that it was made how it’s supposed to be made - she also told me the knots weren’t overcooked when she took them out of the oven - As if we cooked them some more with our oven that we DON’T have here in a clinic! She was very argumentative and unyielding about my our dissatisfaction with the food - I tried multiple times to tell her that the NY style pepperoni pizza looked the same as the regular pizza we ordered when the crust should have been different - yet she kept arguing with me about the size even though I didn’t complain once about the size - Not only did she not make sense but she sounded very sleepy - y’all should check on her - regardless we were stuck with overcooked food because she refused to accept that anything was wrong with it - we will never order from there again - they really act like people don’t have options out here. ———- photos listed for reference
• MM

  MBT

  Aug 23, 2020
  2.0
  I’m not a super fan but my husband likes it. ( maybe not anymore). We got the Shac-a-roni and it was not even close to what they advertise. How can you mess up pepperoni pizza?
• DV

  David Vandivort

  Jul 21, 2017
  1.0
  The last couple of times I've ordered ahead of time delivery they've brought it 20 minutes and 30 minutes ahead of designated time. The pizza is cold a mushy. Calling the manager was a complete waist of time. Clueless on what you do for good customer service. I'm ready to try somewhere else.

Frequently Asked Questions About Papa Johns Pizza