Business Details
About
RestaurantBakeryCafeCoffee Shop
Sarah's on Central is a cafe & cake shop serving breakfast, lunch, dinner and desserts.
Location
Hours
Reviews
4.5
530 reviews
5 stars
413
4 stars
52
3 stars
26
2 stars
14
1 star
25
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Food Quality
Mixed reviews on food quality; some dishes praised as delicious while others were reported as overcooked or lacking flavor.
Service Issues
Service was inconsistent, with reports of slow service, miscommunication, and rude staff experiences.
Atmosphere
Generally positive feedback on the cozy and inviting atmosphere, though some noted it can be noisy when busy.
Desserts
Desserts received high praise, with many customers highlighting their quality and variety.
Pricing Concerns
Several customers felt the prices were high relative to the quality and portion sizes of the food.
- VVVictor ValdesNov 12, 20255.0Excellent food and service
- DBDianne BaginskiOct 28, 20252.0Chicken was overcooked and hard, biscuits were very hard. Not enough gravy on biscuits, Quiche was not creamy and not much spinach on it or mozzarella. Moved from table to table with a long wait. Overpriced coffee $4 each. Tourist trap.
- NONathan OlaoluwaOct 11, 20251.0Ordered a takeout here and they said it’ll take 20mins, it took an hour just for two orders. That’s not even a problem. The entire order was nothing to write home about. They even forgot to put gravy on the biscuit and syrup for waffle. Their loaded potato soup tastes horrible like expired or something - definitely not edible. The food was terrible and a waste of money.
- NBNiki BridgesOct 6, 20255.0Very cute spot on the main street in Eureka. Food is fresh and delicious, with a good portion soze. Cocktails are yummy! Don't forget to get one of their amazing baked goods!
- KCKim ConnellySep 25, 20255.0Breakfast was delicious and came out quickly. Service was friendly, my coffee cup was always full. Will be back to try lunch and dinner.
Frequently Asked Questions About Sarah's on Central
What types of meals does Sarah's on Central serve?
Sarah's on Central serves breakfast, lunch, brunch, and offers a happy hour menu.
What are the operating hours of Sarah's on Central?
Sarah's on Central is open Wednesday and Thursday from 7:30 AM to 6:00 PM, Friday and Saturday from 7:30 AM to 8:00 PM, and Sunday from 8:00 AM to 2:00 PM. The cafe is closed on Mondays and Tuesdays.
Does Sarah's on Central offer pickup and delivery services?
Yes, they offer both in-store pickup and curbside pickup services.
What payment methods are accepted at Sarah's on Central?
They accept American Express, Cash, Check, MasterCard, and Visa.
Can I order catering or custom cakes at Sarah's on Central?
Yes, Sarah's on Central offers catering services and custom cake design.
What is the dress code at Sarah's on Central?
The dress code is casual.
Are cocktails available at Sarah's on Central?
Yes, on Wednesdays and Thursdays the shop remains open until 6 PM for cocktails and desserts.
What nearby places can I visit before or after dining at Sarah's on Central?
You can visit nearby places such as The Extension Lounge salon, Eureka Ice House cafe and ice cream shop, and Joe Boccardi's Ristorante for diverse dining experiences or relaxation.
Is there a nearby place to enjoy wine after visiting Sarah's on Central?
Yes, Eureka Wine House and ArtDog are nearby wine bars where you can enjoy a glass of wine after your visit.
Are there any nearby fitness or recreational venues near Sarah's on Central?
Yes, you can visit Eureka Crossfit for gym and fitness or Black Cat Board Game Library for recreational activities close to Sarah's on Central.