Papa Johns Pizza

Reviews

• KM

  Kelsey Marcus

  Feb 11, 2026
  5.0
  The Papa John’s in Buffalo, Minnesota is hands down one of the most consistent and reliable spots in town. Every time I order, the pizza is hot, fresh, and made exactly how I requested it. The toppings are generous, the cheese is perfectly melted, and the crust has that ideal balance of soft inside with a slight crisp on the outside. The staff here really stands out.. friendly, efficient, and clearly take pride in what they’re doing. Orders are ready on time for pickup, and delivery has always been quick and accurate. Even during busy nights, they keep things moving without sacrificing quality. It’s a great go-to for family dinners, game nights, or when you just don’t feel like cooking. Buffalo is lucky to have such a dependable pizza spot. Highly recommend if you want great service and consistently good pizza!
• KA

  Kaylee Aleshire

  Feb 9, 2026
  5.0
  New restaurant. Very clean, friendly staff! App has great deals. Love the pepperoni pizza and garlic parm breadsticks.
• CB

  Camille Biske

  Feb 6, 2026
  5.0
  We love the new addition to Buffalo, their food is always hot and delicious. It's fast and they have great deals!!! Could not be more pleased with Papa John's!!
• ZZ

  Zah

  Feb 3, 2026
  2.0
  The food has been good but the midday service is awful. When stopping in for carryout, there is zero acknowledgement when you walk in. The guy will look at you, then continue doing whatever he was doing for a few minutes before asking what you want, like your business is some kind of annoyance to him. It’s quite unwelcoming. Around the overly-enthusiastic reviews here - this place is offering free food if you post positive reviews per a flier taped to their front doors.
• AA

  Austin

  Jan 18, 2026
  3.0
  Reviews should be based on this stores merits, not giving a free "10" cheese stick" for a 5 star review. The boneless wings did not have enough sauce. The new york crust and toppings were good, but the sauce is too sweet for my taste. Then lastly the service in the store was slow to pick up and pay for my order.