Einstein Bros. Bagels

Reviews

• SC

  Shelby Chavaux

  2 days ago
  1.0
  Ordered 2 egg sandwiches with avocado on both. Got one without avocado, went up to tell them it was made wrong and the girl (or they/them, sorry not sure) argued with me and said only one sandwich was ordered with avocado. I said no, I paid for both to have it. After going back and forth and her being rude, I had to pull out my receipt and show her the word avocado underneath both sandwiches. It was remade, still not correctly though. I asked for the bagel to be double toasted and it wasn’t. My partners egg sandwich had a spinach florentine bagel and it was mush. His avocado on his sandwich was hard, you couldn’t even mush it with your fingers it was that hard. The einsteins on Rochester road is way better. Always fresh and hot. At this location, our sandwiches were made in 1 minute and yet still cold. We went to go sit on the seats to eat, my partner pulled out a stool and got some sort of gross black dirt or something all over his hands. Stools dirty. Disgusting. Won’t be coming back. Highly suggest driving an extra 10 minutes to a different location.
• PM

  Paul Martin

  Mar 16, 2026
  5.0
  Phenomenal bagels and sandwiches. It is definitely worth the wait or going early to miss the crowds.
• MT

  Mahmoud Tammam

  Mar 13, 2026
  5.0
  Friendly staff, fresh bagels , fun place
• SL

  Sri L

  Feb 24, 2026
  5.0
  Tara helped me out and was very kind. Chris had thanked me for coming in.
• SS

  Sabrina S

  Feb 3, 2026
  4.0
  I have eaten here so many times I lost count. Several years ago, sandwiches were always perfect and delicious, then around or after covid, it got pretty rough, sandwiches would be missing ingredients or just kind of gross. Thankfully it seems like things started to turn around and get better again in 2024/2025. One thing though that they just dont do well is drinks - Sadly I dont think I've ever been happy with a specialty drink (one time my latte had NO coffee in it at all?? The drink was all off-white in color, another time the syrup was overpowering the drink and I could not drink it, another time is was missing syrup, etc.). Coffee is hit or miss. Sometimes its brewed well but sometimes not. I once got iced coffee that was so incredibly bitter that I didnt know coffee could even taste like that. So, while I do recommend the sandwiches, the drinks really kinda stink.