Many customers praised the pizza for its delicious taste, generous toppings, and unique crust, with some calling it the best they've had.
Service Issues
Several reviews highlighted poor service experiences, including long wait times, unhelpful staff, and rude behavior from employees.
Pricing Concerns
Customers expressed mixed feelings about pricing, with some finding it reasonable for the quality, while others felt it was too high for the value received.
Atmosphere
The restaurant's nostalgic, old-school vibe was appreciated by many, although some noted cleanliness issues and maintenance concerns.
Lunch Specials
The $5 lunch special was frequently mentioned as a great deal, offering good value for money with large portions.
AB
Alex Bergel
Dec 5, 2025
5.0
This place is amazing. Their pizza is the best there is down town. Paesano's isn't trying to upset their food by having swanky new decor, a hipster vibe, or cringy topping combos. They're selling damn good pizza at a price that seems like it's still 2007 with a family friendly environment. I can only conclude that this is the reason why they've been there so long and Paesano's will probably outlast us all. Paesano's is the pizza that takes you back to your childhood.
CS
Crystal Spurgeon
Nov 29, 2025
5.0
Delicious pizza 🤤 we make sure to get it every time we come to Traverse City!!
AL
Adrianna Lypeckyj
Nov 26, 2025
5.0
It was a cool and rainy early afternoon, and after walking a mile I decided to go into Paesano's to warm up and get a slice of pizza. The two employees working today were great, one was making the pizza, and the other was waiting on customers. There's a popular five dollar lunch special that includes a large slice of pizza with a side of sauce, two bread sticks, and a beverage. I opted for the $3.50 slice of pizza. It was a generous pizza slice loaded with cheese, homemade sauce, pepperoni, and a chewy crust made from scratch. Eating that slice of pizza with a complimentary side of ranch sauce in the cozy dining room that felt like an old school Italian cafe was so pleasant and enjoyable. Delicious, satisfying pizza at a reasonable price, a charming atmosphere, and a friendly and kind staff is what makes Paesano's my favorite pizzeria in Traverse City. Paesano's is wonderful.
SS
Susan
Nov 21, 2025
1.0
What a dump. I called an ordered a pepperoni pizza, they said 15 minutes. I show up 18 minutes later and they claim I never called and there was no pizza. They refused to look at the caller ID to see if I called. Everyone working in the store looked high and had no clue what they were doing. Probably why they close at 9pm on a Friday and there were 0 pizzas waiting to be picked up.
RC
Renee C
Nov 17, 2025
4.0
This was our first time here. We happened to be in the area and the granddaughter wanted pizza. So, we found this place when we were driving around. Really unique inside, had that old time Italian feeling.
I wish they had pasta or spaghetti something that the granddaughter loves but she did love the pizza. She got a personal pizza and she loved it!
What are Paesano's Pizza's regular operating hours?
Paesano's Pizza is open Wednesday through Sunday. Hours are 11:00 AM to 8:00 PM on Wednesday, Thursday, and Sunday; and 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM on Friday and Saturday. The restaurant is closed on Monday and Tuesday.
Can I order delivery or pickup from Paesano's Pizza?
Yes, Paesano's Pizza offers both in-store pickup and delivery services.
What are the takeout hours for Paesano's Pizza?
Takeout is available Wednesday through Sunday from 11:00 AM to 8:00 PM on Wednesday, Thursday, and Sunday, and from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM on Friday and Saturday. Closed on Monday and Tuesday.
Where is Paesano's Pizza located?
Paesano's Pizza is located at 447 E Front St, Traverse City, MI 49686, United States.
How can I view the menu or place an order online at Paesano's Pizza?
You can view the menu and place an order online at https://paesanospizza.com/menu.
What is the price range at Paesano's Pizza?
The price range at Paesano's Pizza is moderate, classified as 'TWO'.
What kind of restaurant is Paesano's Pizza?
Paesano's Pizza is a pizza restaurant that also offers pizza delivery and takeaway services.
Are there any beauty salons near Paesano's Pizza where customers could visit before or after dining?
Yes, Bir Taraf and Pure Essence Salon are nearby beauty salons, perfect for customers looking to enjoy a beauty or hair treatment before or after their meal.
What nearby stores could I explore when visiting Paesano's Pizza?
Nearby you can visit thrift and clothing stores like Penny Lane and Skull & Tendah Vintage, ideal for shoppers who want to browse unique finds before or after enjoying pizza.
Are there any nearby dessert or coffee shops close to Paesano's Pizza?
Yes, Sweet Tartlette and Peace, Love and Little Donuts are nearby dessert and coffee shops where you can enjoy sweet treats or coffee near Paesano's Pizza.