Papa Johns Pizza

Reviews

• M6

  Marie 6

  6 days ago
  1.0
  Pizza was cold before I got home. Cheese looked dry, no shine or grease. Wont be back.
• KB

  Kristy Bash

  Feb 17, 2026
  4.0
  Love having a new pizza place in town honestly. Get sick of the same old. They do a pretty good job and are also pretty quick.
• RN

  Randall Nielsen

  Jan 22, 2026
  1.0
  Not very impressed topping very little even when ask for extra sausage the establishment looks like someone just find empty building and throw a business in it ordered garlic bread stick and they were plain be a while if ever go back there
• BY

  Barry Yoakam

  Jan 11, 2026
  1.0
  My very first time ordering. Ordered a Philly cheesesteak pizza. The food was perfect. As it turned out it was the absolute most expensive pizza I’ve ever had. The pizza cost was reasonable, however the delivery driver was rude. Opened a closed gate to go to the unlit front door. The side door on the driveway with its light on and easy access wasn’t used. I directed the delivery person that the front door wasn’t used in the winter. She promptly said very rudely “ YOU NEED TO INCLUDE THAT IN THE DELIVERY INSTRUCTIONS “. She came to the side door, delivered my pizza. After I took the pizza she held out her hand for a tip. I said have a nice day ( I tipped her through the app) the tip was the middle tip selection. Wish i had not tipped her. After dinner I took my dog out to find the front gate wide open and my mailbox post broken. I looked over the video and the driver backed up, drove forward into my mailbox breaking the post, she then left. After work I proceeded to go into the store to inform them of the damage. They took my name and number. I received a call and text from the manager inquiring about the incident. They want copies of video, pictures of the post to prove the damage to my property. I sent them a copy of the receipt for damages. $40.00 for the post, 2.5 hours labor to get the post, transfer the mailbox and paper tube. And replace the post in the frozen ground. As I told them I don’t want them to do shit. I’ll take my loss and NEVER EVER BUY ANYTHING FROM THEM! This being my first experience with Poppa John’s pizza it was expensive, delivery was rude and left a bad taste in my mouth. NEVER AGAIN WILL I GET PIZZA FROM THEM AGAIN!!
• NB

  Nonya Business

  Jan 1, 2026
  5.0
  Had delivery, not worried about how long it takes, but my food was less than warm. Was still good, but I do like Hot food. I suggest you look at management, alot of reviews I noticed complain about barley warm or cold food. Papa John's disappeared from south haven before, do us a favor and learn from mistakes, $1.09 for a sauce thats already super small and its half full, so two of those for $2 something that made almost 1 full sauce

Frequently Asked Questions About Papa Johns Pizza