Customer experiences with service were highly variable, with some praising specific servers like Mitch and Michelle for their attentiveness, while others reported long wait times and poor service.
Food Quality
While many customers enjoyed the food, particularly the wings, there were numerous complaints about incorrect orders, cold food, and inconsistent quality.
Takeout Issues
Several reviews highlighted significant problems with takeout orders, including missing items and incorrect preparations, leading to frustration among customers.
Atmosphere and Cleanliness
The restaurant's atmosphere received mixed reviews, with some noting cleanliness and a pleasant environment, while others reported unclean tables and poor seating experiences.
Pricing Concerns
Customers expressed dissatisfaction with pricing, citing high costs for food that did not meet expectations, particularly regarding portion sizes and quality.
BB
Braydan Ballard
Nov 7, 2025
5.0
Lacy was amazing! Made the experience perfect!
LP
Lexi Polezoes
Oct 20, 2025
5.0
Reasonable prices, burger and wings were amazing & Mitch was a wonderful server! He went above and beyond and ensured we had everything we needed plus more! Best service I’ve had since moving up north, we appreciate you so much Mitch, keep up the great work!
TT
Trevor Temple
Oct 17, 2025
2.0
First of all no one answers the phone. Secondly I did an online order of traditional wings and plan boneless wings I got all boneless wings all with sauce on them
PS
Peter Stover
Oct 11, 2025
2.0
Poor service from the start. Waiting 5 minutes just to be seated. Long wait for mediocre food to arrive. Staff uninterested in providing quality service. Been to numerous BWW and unfortunately this location continues to be a disappointment.
LW
Laneisha Wright
Sep 27, 2025
1.0
So went here for dinner last night… first we waited for almost 10mins to get seated… BUT it was no one else waiting… we were standing there while ppl walked passed us and no one said NOTHING! Finally the bartender came over to the hostess station… she passively said to follow her… she did ask booth or table … she walked to the booth pointed and kept walking… ( she didn’t say someone would be with you all or can I get you started)… so we begin to look at the menu… and wait … and wait … and wait … and wait… after 15 mins of no one coming over to us, after 15 mins of servers walking pass just looking at us… 15 mins of being the only black ppl in the entire building … we decided to leave..
So I’m sure you’re wondering why did we stay so long… well our 4hr 15min drive up north turned into over 5hrs (construction)… this was the only thing open that late and my babies (my daughter and niece) were hungry.
I’m so angry they had to experience that because we teach them to love everyone because we’re part of the HUMAN race and that’s the only race that should matter!
IF YOU COME TO PETOSKEY, MI DO NOT GO TO BUFFALO WILD WINGS!!
Frequently Asked Questions About Buffalo Wild Wings
What type of cuisine does Buffalo Wild Wings in Petoskey offer?
Buffalo Wild Wings in Petoskey offers award-winning Buffalo, New York-style chicken wings with 26 different sauces and seasonings to choose from.
What are the operating hours for Buffalo Wild Wings in Petoskey?
Buffalo Wild Wings is open Monday through Sunday from 11:00 AM with closing times varying between 11:00 PM and midnight. Specifically, it closes at 11:00 PM Sunday through Wednesday and at midnight Thursday through Saturday.
Where is Buffalo Wild Wings located in Petoskey?
Buffalo Wild Wings is located at 1965 Waabizhish Drive, Petoskey, MI 49770, USA.
Is Buffalo Wild Wings in Petoskey currently open?
Buffalo Wild Wings in Petoskey is currently open and operating.
How can I contact Buffalo Wild Wings in Petoskey?
You can contact Buffalo Wild Wings in Petoskey by phone at +1 231-439-9153.
Can I find Buffalo Wild Wings on social media or online?
Yes, Buffalo Wild Wings in Petoskey has official pages and websites on Facebook, Yelp, Google, and their main website for more information.
What kind of dining experience is offered at Buffalo Wild Wings in Petoskey?
Buffalo Wild Wings offers a sports bar and casual dining experience specializing in chicken wings and takeout options.
What nearby dining options are available around Buffalo Wild Wings in Petoskey?
Nearby dining options include Corktown Pizza, Applebee's S-Petoskey, Tropical Smoothie Cafe, Pizza Hut, and Bob Evans, providing a variety of choices for pizza, American cuisine, smoothies, and breakfast.
Are there any nearby services that can complement a visit to Buffalo Wild Wings in Petoskey?
Yes, nearby services include Metro by T-Mobile and T-Mobile for mobile phone needs, Great Clips for hair styling, and AutoZone for automotive parts and repair.
What entertainment or media establishments are located near Buffalo Wild Wings in Petoskey?
Nearby entertainment and media locations include Star Country 106.7 radio station, 102.3 & 103.3 FM Triple Talk WMKT, Lite 96.3 Petoskey/Traverse City Michigan, MacDonald Garber Broadcasting, and 106 KHQ radio station.