Several customers reported long wait times for food and drinks, as well as forgetful or inattentive service from staff.
Food Quality
While many reviews praised the food as delicious and well-prepared, there were also complaints about specific dishes being subpar or not meeting expectations.
Atmosphere
The restaurant's festive decorations and arcade games were frequently highlighted as enjoyable aspects, contributing to a fun and inviting environment.
Staff Praise
Certain staff members received high praise for their exceptional service, with specific names mentioned as standout servers.
Mixed Experiences
Overall, customer experiences varied widely, with some expressing strong satisfaction while others reported significant disappointments.
TM
Tyana Misiuda
Dec 28, 2025
3.0
It was a cute Christmas atmosphere however three adults ordered drinks and I had to get up separately to ask for my drink which was just sitting at the bar. Food was pretty good but again at the end my brother in law ordered a drink that never came. We had to ask for it to be removed from the bill. We would consider going back but definitely won’t be rushing to try it again.
SH
samantha horning
Dec 27, 2025
5.0
First time here and everything was great! We got the pickle chips and tots for appetizers and those were amazing. The chicken sandwich and turkey rueben was perfect, fries are crispy and the drinks were made not too strong and not too weak. We will definitely be back, next time for the pizza!
AG
autumn greer
Dec 20, 2025
1.0
I don’t typically write bad reviews and i’m not the person to make a review ever on social media, the waitress was very forgetful.
We had several issues during our visit- i was given a diet pesi when i asked for regular- the waitress never brought a new one when asked.
i advised the waitress no tomato or mayo and had mayo on it.
We asked for an appeitizer and never got it.
The waitress not once checked on our table and we had to have another waitress from a different section check on us as our waitress dissapeared for 30+ minutes.
All we got was “.75 cents off for a disssatiafed customer”
Food was good but had better expectations.
NN
Nik Nak
Dec 17, 2025
4.0
Our waitress was Kaitlyn and she was absolutely amazing! It was decorated very cute and the drinks were both cute and tasty! My daughters liked the cheese pizza and the grilled cheese and my husband liked his cheeseburger. We tried the martini flight, Christmas mojito, Christmas cookie martini, and the gingerbread old fashioned and they were all delicious. The atmosphere was great as well. Any of the staff that we interacted with were super nice! Above all, it was Kaitlyn that stood out the most! She is the reason we would come back. Her attention to detail, care for our entire table, and communication was top notch. My aunt's sugar was dropping and she offered her own personal candy as well as any other help that she could while we waited for our food. She was great!
Note: there was a pretty decent wait for food, so be prepared
CW
Connie Wirtz
Dec 16, 2025
3.0
We were in for Thanksgiving as a group & the girl behind the bar was the only one working the floor. We felt bad for her, she had no help.
Frequently Asked Questions About The Pickled Goat Bar & Grill
What are the regular operating hours of The Pickled Goat Bar & Grill?
The Pickled Goat Bar & Grill is open Tuesday to Sunday from 11:00 AM. Closing hours vary: 10:00 PM on Tuesday and Wednesday, 9:00 PM on Thursday, midnight on Friday and Saturday, and 8:00 PM on Sunday. The restaurant is closed on Mondays.
Is The Pickled Goat Bar & Grill open on Mondays?
No, The Pickled Goat Bar & Grill is closed on Mondays.
Does The Pickled Goat Bar & Grill offer delivery and in-store pickup services?
Yes, The Pickled Goat Bar & Grill offers both in-store pickup and delivery services.
What types of cuisine and dining experiences does The Pickled Goat Bar & Grill offer?
The Pickled Goat Bar & Grill is a Bar & Grill featuring American cuisine, including pizza, sandwiches, hamburgers, chicken wings, and fast food. It also has a video arcade and cocktail bar atmosphere, making it a suitable family restaurant.
Where is The Pickled Goat Bar & Grill located?
The Pickled Goat Bar & Grill is located at 51083 Washington St, New Baltimore, MI 48047, United States.
Where can I view the menu or place an order online for The Pickled Goat Bar & Grill?
You can view the menu and place orders online at https://thepickledgoatbar.com/menu.
What nearby restaurants can I visit around The Pickled Goat Bar & Grill?
Nearby restaurants include The Local Goat Bar & Grill, Little Camille's By The Bay (Mexican), Downtown Pitstop Cafe, City Cafe, The Little Mustard Seed Cafe and Coffee, On The Bay Boutique, and Fin's Eatery & Spirits (seafood).
Are there local museums or historical sites near The Pickled Goat Bar & Grill to visit?
Yes, nearby you can visit the Grand Pacific House Museum and the New Baltimore Historical Society to learn about local history.
What other services and shops are near The Pickled Goat Bar & Grill for visitors to explore?
Nearby you can find salons like Creative Images Salon and Le Beauté, wellness centers such as Infinite Grace Counseling and Wellness, and ice cream shops including Lil Sweet Boutique and House Of Ice Cream and More.
How can nearby points of interest help customers visiting The Pickled Goat Bar & Grill?
Nearby dining options, entertainment venues like the video arcade, and attractions such as museums and salons make visiting the area convenient for a full day experience. Customers can enjoy meals at nearby restaurants or visit local museums before or after dining at The Pickled Goat Bar & Grill.